News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama Calls for Patent Reform to Topple Trolls by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 16, 2013 @01:23AM (#5230624)
>1) Reforms on how damages are calculated. If you neither sell a product nor license IP to third parties, there is no way you're losing any revenue from an infringement. You should not be awarded even "reasonable royalty" damages if you wouldn't have received any royalties in any case.

What stops them just publishing a sham product whose sole purpose is to be for sale while infringing the patent and then show a few licenses to a couple of fishing buddies?

The real trouble with how damages are calculated for software patents is that there is no good way to determine the degree to which the patent was integral to the success of the product, and juries have had a tendency to grossly overestimate their value. Witness Apple v. Samsung.

I imagine your typical smart phone infringes probably twenty or thirty thousand software patents. Even if you assume that every penny of the device's price is attributable solely to patents (and nothing for, say, manufacturing, shipping or advertising), and the device "only" infringes 10,000 patents, the average value of one of those patents against the sale of ten million $500 devices would be $500,000. Which would hardly be even worth litigating over, given that the lawyers cost more than that. But there is no real way to prove that any given patent subscribes to the averages, and plaintiffs will naturally argue that their patent is worth more than all the other patents, and the jury who finds for them on infringement is predisposed to agree on damages as well. So we get billion dollar awards that should be sub-million dollar awards and the trolls get fully funded to buy more radiological weapons and lobby hard for their own continued existence.

>A lot of troll litigation could be shut down quickly if patent infringement functioned similarly to copyright infringement in requiring direct copying.

What standard could you use to prove that? Correct me if I'm wrong, but if I recall copyright is "similarity and access" and for published works "access" is kind of a formality (because everybody has access), which is why the degree of similarity requires a significant amount of specificity. I don't imagine you could find anyone to argue that Chrome infringes the copyright on Firefox as a result of their similarity.

But that's not going to cut it with patents. The intent of drafting a patent claim is to make it as broad as possible while still getting it through the patent office. Any non-mandatory specificity is the enemy. The only way you could give defendants any hope of actually proving that they didn't copy a patent under a standard like that would be to crank the level of specificity required in patent claims up to the point where you'll just have reinvented copyright and called it a patent.

Which is kind of the issue. Copyright works really well for software. The implementation is the hard part, and that is the part that copyright covers. Patents just don't work at all -- because there are so many ways to implement something in software that the only way a third party would ever actually infringe a software patent is to allow it to be so broad that it covers the problem itself rather than any specific solution to it (e.g. shopping cart patents), or covers any implementation that applies the mathematical formula that describes the optimized result for a specific problem dictated by information theory (e.g. encoding or encryption patents).

Re:Obama Calls for Patent Reform to Topple Trolls by rayiner on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:28AM (#5230767)
You make excellent points, but I have a bone to pick with your last one: "Copyright works really well for software. The implementation is the hard part, and that is the part that copyright covers."

Whether design or implementation is the hard part depends entirely what kind of software you're building. Think of something like Google's self-driving car. I can't imagine that the hard part of that is just sitting down and writing the code.

Re:Obama Calls for Patent Reform to Topple Trolls by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 16, 2013 @10:59AM (#5231820)
>Whether design or implementation is the hard part depends entirely what kind of software you're building. Think of something like Google's self-driving car. I can't imagine that the hard part of that is just sitting down and writing the code.

That's kind of what I'm talking about. You can't get a patent claim on "a self-driving car" -- and if you do the patent office has failed miserably. Software patents don't cover the overall product, they cover the building blocks you use to make one. And each of the individual building blocks is not the hard part, the hard part is the overall implementation -- assembling them all into a cohesive whole that accomplishes the major goal you set out to achieve.

You want someone who starts with the Google self-driving car and sets out to copy it to have a hard time of it legally, so that they decide instead to do their own independent implementation and have their own costs (and maybe advance the field themselves) so that they can't just undercut Google having done no R&D, but at the same time still make it so that they can do an independent implementation without infringing. Those are the two important criteria.

Copyright pretty well does the first one. If you can't just copy Google's code out of their car and put it in yours, you have to write some tens of millions or more lines of code yourself. And then you have to test it and stamp out the bugs, which is by far the most expensive part of producing software in practice. (I expect this goes double when the thing you're making is a car.) Patents don't really add very much on top of that -- if someone is already doing an independent implementation, having to work around a patent is a small incremental cost, especially if the issued patent is not so broad that it covers the problem itself rather than a specific solution.

Which brings us back to the trouble: In order for the patent system to do anything for software R&D, you can't just have one patent, you need thousands. Which thoroughly violates the second criteria -- now no one can do an independent implementation without accidentally stepping on some fraction of the outlandish number of issued software patents. To clear yourself you have to clear tens or hundreds of thousands of issued patents, but to sue you the plaintiffs need only find a single patent for which you failed to do so. And to shake you down they don't even need to do that, as long as the cost of proving they're full of crap in court is more than the amount they're demanding for a license. These costs vastly exceed any possible incremental benefit over copyright of having software patents at all.

Re:Obama Calls for Patent Reform to Topple Trolls by jonpeda on Sunday February 17, 2013 @12:25PM (#5235874)
> What stops them just publishing a sham product whose sole purpose is to be for sale while infringing the patent and then show a few licenses to a couple of fishing buddies?

The courts are adept at investigating those issues. For example, Enron's sham electricity sales were discovered once the files were opened.