News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Expect IBM to leave Vermont within three years (2012) by larrys on Thursday February 14, 2013 @10:38AM (#5219895)
"Does it mean that Americans are loosing jobs? no. But it is easy to skew the numbers when you only show that IBM is shedding jobs. But when it is all tallied some of those jobs are being replaced with US based contract labor."

Agree.

Two points. One - I know that when ATT did layoffs in the 80's many (or at least some I knew these people) of those laid off got contracts with ATT as subs and used them to build up companies.

Second what you are saying also goes to the heart of the issue of job creation. People talk about startups creating jobs. But there is only so much purchasing power in the economy. A startup offering a product or service that is charging is going to take purchasing power away from a consumer or business that is most likely already spending that money somewhere. The only net gains sometimes are only if a country can take jobs from another country or a state or region can take jobs from another state or region or city.

Re:Expect IBM to leave Vermont within three years (2012) by infinite8s on Thursday February 14, 2013 @10:59AM (#5220007)
> Second what you are saying also goes to the heart of the issue of job creation. People talk about startups creating jobs. But there is only so much purchasing power in the economy. A startup offering a product or service that is charging is going to take purchasing power away from a consumer or business that is most likely already spending that money somewhere. The only net gains sometimes are only if a country can take jobs from another country or a state or region can take jobs from another state or region or city.

That's the flawed zero-sum perception of economics, and history has proved that wrong. If it was true we'd still be living in caves and providing everything for ourselves.

Re:Expect IBM to leave Vermont within three years (2012) by kls on Thursday February 14, 2013 @11:15AM (#5220086)
In sense larrys is right, but your observations is correct as well, at any given time there is only so much wealth in a society and the division of that wealth will happen any way you assemble it. But to your point, there are periods of innovation that create new and novel wealth that expands the pool for everybody. But after that innovation period is over, consolidation and efforts to streamline happen. IBM is in that streamlining period in portions of their business while in others (Watson for example) they are very much in the innovation phase.
Re:Expect IBM to leave Vermont within three years (2012) by travem on Thursday February 14, 2013 @12:30PM (#5220555)
I think Clayton Christensen covers this well when he discusses empowering, sustaining and efficiency innovation.

The following for a brief introduction http://www.deseretnews.com/article/765617333/The-new-church-...

Re:Expect IBM to leave Vermont within three years (2012) by eli_gottlieb on Thursday February 14, 2013 @11:14AM (#5220083)
It's flawed over all space and time, yes, but it's true in a recession when total economic output (or at least, total economic output as available to the bottom 99% of the population) is shrinking.