I don't disagree, but do you have anything to back this up?
I ask because my girlfriend is a teacher, and teaching is a lot harder than most people seem to believe.
Like what? Numbers and studies? Khan Academy said that they have very promising results in which students perform significantly better on standardized tests.
That being said, I already wrote in my post how we can improve efficiency and effectiveness by leveraging computers for all they're worth. I think this is sufficient to show how dated the teaching is done in schools, if not exactly proves how inefficient our school teach. I think it's quite obvious that it's better to watch a recorded lecture than to see the teacher perform the same lecture years after year.
I ask because my girlfriend is a teacher, and teaching is a lot harder than most people seem to believe.
All I am advocating is giving the teachers and students better tools based on cognitive science that we discovered a long time ago. Making sure students get the practice they need on summer vacations and scheduling practice problems to reduce unnecessary studying isn't rocket science.
Without numbers and studies, this sounds like self-selection to me - people doing Khan Academy courses are surely more self-motivated than people attending colleges and universities, a substantial percentage of whom probably don't really enjoy being there.
I think it's quite obvious that it's better to watch a recorded lecture than to see the teacher perform the same lecture years after year.
Do you mean obvious from some study you've heard of, or obvious to you? Because that's not at all obvious to me personally - in fact, the opposite is true. I think I learn much better from in-person lecturers (providing the lecturer is good, which would have to be true in a video lecture too). I think there are two forces at play that make this true - first, the lecturer can gauge the response of the audience and tailor his presentation - timing, level of explanation etc. Second, the atmosphere makes me pay attention more - in much the same way as going to the cinema or to see a play in a theater is more engaging that watching the same thing on TV or YouTube.
I know that basically everything I've said is all anecdote and presumption, but my presumption seem just as valid (to me, more valid :-P) than yours in the absence of hard data.
On your point that we should [give] the teachers and students better tools based on cognitive science that we discovered a long time ago, I wholeheartedly agree, but it needs to be done based on scientific conclusions, not anecdata (yours or mine).
Spaced repetition and spacing effect is well known science and it works. For everything else I said, there should be more studies and experiments.
And why should essentially randomly virally selected people be labelled self-selected, any more than any people who answer an ad for a psychological study? From those in the group, statistics can be gleaned by including factors like age and economics.
And there are lots of reasons a lecture you can repeat, stop, talk to a buddy about real-time is better than an assembly-hall lecture. This is obvious to those paying attention to the Khan Academy movement.
Ah, actually, it's not.
For instance, a number of studies unequivocally showed that an infant learns nothing in front of an televised education program. A young child cannot learn a language from a visual recording, but somehow can if the child sees the same thing live. Somehow the screen seems to screen of the magic.
As we get older and learn to focus our attention ourselves, this becomes less important. But direct human contact, even through a mere lecture, still counts. So my guess is that while mechanised teaching (not just videos —we' have computers for Omega's sake!) has certainly great potential, merely replacing the teacher by a computer, even part time, is probably not optimal.
Originally, I thought it was a money problem, but some schools have a ridiculous budget and are happy to spend them on the same old stuff. Why is no one investing in these things that will apparently improve education?
See, for example, the length of time that it's taken to get synthetic phonics over analytic phonics recognised as better for teaching children to read.
What part of learning that doesn't involves remembering and building a foundation on what you have learned? What if you forgot your basic when you have to do more advanced stuff. That is part of the process of "learning".
Yes, it is, and it have nothing to do with our funding. The way we teach is extraordinary inefficient and outdated.
For example, spaced repetition is a learning technique that takes advantage of the spacing effect phenomenon that is present in all humans. You know why your teachers told you to study everyday instead of cramming? Well, cramming doesn't help you retain information in the long run! Computers can be used to track every answers and problem, what our weakness are, and to schedule when to review, allowing us to take spaced repetition to its logical conclusion. The computer can generate problems on demand, give out recorded lectures by the very best teacher, and so on.
Spacing effects also implies summer vacation is harmful to knowledge acquisition process unless we continuously practice. When we finish high school and college, decays begin to set in because we stop practicing. The result is that countless generation learned mathematics, history, language art, literature, only to forget upon exiting formal education.
That's why khanacademy is so powerful. They really do leverage computers to generate problems, explain stuff, track your every mistakes, and schedule practices problem using spaced repetition. Right now, long run khanacademy users like me knows more and is the most refreshed on mathematics than the vast majority of high school students and working adults. We practice math problems everyday, thus ensuring that we never forget and be prepared to build a new knowledge as soon as Khan Academy adds new exercises or revise old one.
That's in contrast to going to a very inefficient traditional institutions and receiving a "great education" and then immediately forgetting most of what you're taught. That's a very inefficient way to learn.