News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by cobrausn on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @05:12PM (#5216026)
In a company with a well known lack of traditional corporate hierarchy, who does the firing? I'm genuinely curious. None of the reports I've read have mentioned it, which leads you to assume Gabe. This would imply an informal hierarchy.
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by LandoCalrissian on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @05:21PM (#5216075)
I recall reading a while back that they have a procedure for this. I think they actually decide it through group consensus, so I would imagine the reasons for being fired would have to be pretty real.
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by mercuryrising on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @05:36PM (#5216164)
That kind of sucks actually... If I was getting fired from a job, knowing that more than half (or whatever percent) of the people felt I was incompetent and should be fired would really rock the friendships I made.

Having a manager fire you gives you a lightning rod to point the feelings at, rather than an entire group of people.

Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by campnic on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @05:41PM (#5216201)
If i was designing it, you'd need to make it focused on the products. Maybe 50% of people feel these products are not 'viable'. If thats the feeling, I think that those fired can walk away feeling ok about the situation (obviously not great).
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by avar on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @06:16PM (#5216363)
That's a horrible criteria. Maybe you have a really talented employee who just happens to be working on a doomed product. The right thing to do is to move that employee to a more viable project, not to fire them just because they're working on a dead project.
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by michaelochurch on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @06:09PM (#5216338)
Firing by group consensus is, I agree, not tenable. This is one point in time where the CEO needs to step up and take a "buck stops here" attitude.

There are generally 3 types of job loss:

1. People who are unethical or obviously toxic. Here, management can step in and fire the person without much blowback. If someone steals, or is a direct threat to your culture (e.g. he starts playing politics and trying to set himself up as the executive empire-builder you don't want) then it's not very controversial.

2. Good employees who run afoul of political nonsense or parochial managerial politics. This is what companies like Valve are trying to avoid, because it poisons the culture.

3. Layoffs for economic reasons.

I assume this is a case of #3. The CEO needs to explain what happened, why it happened, take responsibility for the decision, and assure people that the company will be better after the change than before.

Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by x3sphere on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @07:43PM (#5216811)
Doubtful. Valve has higher revenue per employee than Google or Apple. If there's anything Valve lacks, money is last on the list.
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by michaelochurch on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @10:05PM (#5217422)
Economic reasons != money problems. It seems possible that there's a long-term strategic change going on.
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by cma on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @11:04PM (#5217646)
You are spamming the thread (and every other thread that is even tangentially related to open allocation). You've literally made hundreds of posts about open allocation in the last few months. Give other people a chance to talk.
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by Nav_Panel on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @11:25PM (#5217712)
So what? He's contributing reasonably decent comments, who cares if he posts a lot?

Comment sections are essentially infinite, and if the comments are good, I don't see any reason to tell him to stop. However, if the comments are not insightful/interesting, that's another story.

Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by cma on Thursday February 14, 2013 @12:07AM (#5217844)
Some of his comments are great, but many just repeat the same talking points. You can't be saying that as long as someone says something insightful they can copy/paste it into as many HN threads as they like, so long as it is on topic.
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by Evbn on Thursday February 14, 2013 @11:42PM (#5224492)
Tokenadult is consistently the top ranked commenter when he pastes her boilrplate into every education or hiring discussion.
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by trdtaylor on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @05:29PM (#5216119)
Yes, it's in the employee handbook posted last year. Peer evaluations that actually work compared to the Microsoft system Gabe left behind.
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by danso on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @05:33PM (#5216151)
IIRC, the employee handbook pretty much said that you can work on whatever you want, and choose your own departments. So when doing layoffs, are peer evaluation scores compared companywide (as opposed to just saying, we're letting you go because we're shutting down your department/project).
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by epsylon on Thursday February 14, 2013 @07:03AM (#5219062)
In the present case, it's a massive layoff and the decision seems to have staid secret internally (https://twitter.com/tom_forsyth/status/301586785899782144), so I'd guess it's a hierarchical decision, with no internal consultation.
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by ars on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @05:21PM (#5216074)
Somebody owns the company no? Someone writes the checks? That person does the firing.
Re:Several out of work as Valve makes 'large decisions' abou... by michaelochurch on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @06:03PM (#5216313)
This is one time when, even for an anti-hierarchical company, you can't afford to be a democracy. You need a strong leader to communicate the layoff, the reasoning, and the strategic ramifications going forward.

Another element to the art of layoffs is that you get about one shot every 5 years. One large cut can be painful, but it's not damaging to morale if it's well-justified by business or economic concerns. If you do a series of small cuts, that's when you get people paranoid and the alliances and intrigues start to form.

So, I think the best way to do a layoff in a Valve-style corporation is this:

(1) Fair severance, including career support (positive reference, right to represent self as employed). People will find out what kinds of packages people are getting.

(2) CEO communicates the decision to the whole company and takes full responsibility. No mystical "calibration scores" or HR indirections. He gets up and says, "This is what I did, and here's why I had to do it." I'm not talking about traditional hierarchy, but "buck stops here" leadership. That's needed when layoffs are happening.

(3) Unless the people actually are being fired, explain that it is a layoff and that the people will be eligible to re-apply when you start hiring. (Most won't come back, but this lets the rest of the team feel better about the whole thing.)

(4) Err on the side of a larger layoff, because a series of small cuts is more damaging.

(5) Impose a hiring freeze externally, but keep internal mobility as it is. Many companies impose internal hiring freezes during layoffs and that's actually more damaging.

ETA

(6) Make it very clear that these aren't performance-based firings. The worst is when a company tries to depict a layoff as performance-based. Layoffs are understandable, but trying to depict one as a performance-based firing is being a dick.