News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Apology by jessaustin on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @02:09PM (#5214989)
Was that a real Joan Didion quote?

Seriously, he's correct in many of the things he said, but he's probably the wrong person to be saying this. Perhaps in a couple of decades he might be the right person. Humans really are flawed creatures. We really do screw up all the time. It really isn't enough to be governed by a strong moral compass: that sense of morality must be assisted by the wisdom to avoid situations that will corrupt it. Strong habits, traditions, or even "standard operating procedures" assist the wise in this avoidance.

I still have sympathy for this guy. My suspicion is that those in the media who are really piling on, are doing so at least partially to avoid hearing what's being said. Lehrer is bad, so we can't admit that most of what he did, we do if only to a lesser degree. Otherwise we would be bad. This sort of binary morality is really primitive and pathetic, but many people don't have anything else available to them.

If's fine if you don't sympathize with Lehrer as I do, but I don't understand how people can complain that he brought up the FBI lab as an example. Why would they be above him? He didn't send any innocent people to jail! If you'd like proof that this is a serious problem, read up on the mess they have in Mississippi with bogus forensics. If Lehrer does anything to improve forensics in this country, all his plagiarism will have been worth it.

Re:My Apology by DigitalJack on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @02:25PM (#5215100)
I think he is the right person to be saying this. And I'd like to read an update in a year or two as well, see how it's working out for him.

Frankly the state of US journalism is so weighed down by bias, the institution in general could probably use a dose of the Checklist Manifesto. And if this guy can come up with some SOPs that work for him, he should publish them and maybe they can help others who are willing.

I think a lot of the HN reaction to this is understandable. It's akin to a fall down drunk getting his 30 day chip, and announcing it to the world.

But Lehrer didn't sound like he was proud of his "30 day chip", just that he's starting to see what the road to wellness is going to take. It's the first step in his making amends.

People can take what he offers and accept it, disregard it, chew him up and spit him on the ground, or whatever. But at least he is offering something. That's his part. I'll be interested to see how he does and where he goes.

Re:My Apology by ScottBurson on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @02:52PM (#5215254)
> Lehrer is bad, so we can't admit that most of what he did, we do if only to a lesser degree. Otherwise we would be bad.

Yes. The technical psychoanalytic term is "projection".

There's lots of it out there if you look.

Re:My Apology by jessaustin on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @03:33PM (#5215495)
Oy! I intentionally don't look for it, but still I see it everywhere!
Re:My Apology by pdonis on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @03:45PM (#5215550)
It really isn't enough to be governed by a strong moral compass: that sense of morality must be assisted by the wisdom to avoid situations that will corrupt it.

I don't think he was governed by a "strong moral compass" in the first place. "Don't plagiarize" is a pretty simple rule to follow; not being able to follow it does not indicate a strong moral compass with a lack of wisdom; it indicates a weak moral compass to begin with.

My suspicion is that those in the media who are really piling on, are doing so at least partially to avoid hearing what's being said.

This may well be true; I think many people in the media do the same things Lehrer did, they just haven't been caught yet. But that doesn't give me any more sympathy for Lehrer; it gives me less sympathy for the media in general.

Re:My Apology by usefulcat on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @03:49PM (#5215576)
If someone is willing to plagiarize, I have a hard time seeing how any set of "standard operating procedures" is going to help that person to refrain from plagiarizing in the future.
Re:My Apology by jessaustin on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @04:20PM (#5215751)
See, this is the sort of binary morality I was talking about. You could plug any bad act into the "plagiarize" slot and your statement would have precisely the same content. The Lehrer who existed three years ago didn't plagiarize all the time, and he probably didn't realize he was plagiarizing at least part of the time he was doing it. He plagiarized in specific situations, and furthermore he probably brought about those situations through his own actions (e.g., exempting himself from fact-checking on a problematic article by concocting an excuse his editor would buy), even if he didn't realize it at the time. Today's Lehrer can endeavor to avoid those situations, and certainly to never bring them about through his own actions, just by being more aware.

I don't say this to excuse Lehrer's actions. All of us humans are the same flawed creatures as he, and we're all judged for our actions. I don't have to believe in the devil, but if I can imagine him, I can imagine a fiend who tempts all humanity, virtuous or not. Then I can make ready for his temptations even though I'm not a bad person like Lehrer.

Re:My Apology by usefulcat on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @06:05PM (#5216327)
I'm not here to moralize. In at least some cases, he clearly copied and pasted and then did some minor edits. I don't see how that could have happened accidentally, and therefore I don't think it's unreasonable to ask how having a set of rules is going to help (given that, obviously, it will typically require a certain amount of diligence to follow any set of rules). I'm not saying that it won't help, but if it will, it would certainly be instructive to understand exactly how.