Re:Ask HN: It is "moral" to copy someone else's idea?
by 7402 on Monday February 11, 2013 @01:13PM
(#5202215)
There may actually be a good reason why you're feeling guilty. And it may in fact be a better plan to do something else.
You can try the following thought experiment: suppose you follow through on this new business, spend 6 months working on it, and a month after it gets going, someone ELSE copies the idea, does it a little better than you, and your sales go to zero. How will you feel?
You might think, "Well, all's fair in love, war, and startups. I made a good attempt, learned a whole lot, and I got beat fair and square. It doesn't really bother me, that is how the game is played. Now I'll try something else."
Or, you might think, "Wow. I just wasted 6 months. I didn't gain any new skills. I don't feel good about what I did. I wish I had spent that time doing something to improve myself."
Or, you might feel, "I WAS ROBBED. I spent all this time working on a real improvement on web site X, but web site Y just ripped me off and benefited from my 6 months of hard work."
Never mind what you think is the "right" answer - you might be happier in the long run trying to think of something new, or at least spending your efforts on learning something new.
You can try the following thought experiment: suppose you follow through on this new business, spend 6 months working on it, and a month after it gets going, someone ELSE copies the idea, does it a little better than you, and your sales go to zero. How will you feel?
You might think, "Well, all's fair in love, war, and startups. I made a good attempt, learned a whole lot, and I got beat fair and square. It doesn't really bother me, that is how the game is played. Now I'll try something else."
Or, you might think, "Wow. I just wasted 6 months. I didn't gain any new skills. I don't feel good about what I did. I wish I had spent that time doing something to improve myself."
Or, you might feel, "I WAS ROBBED. I spent all this time working on a real improvement on web site X, but web site Y just ripped me off and benefited from my 6 months of hard work."
Never mind what you think is the "right" answer - you might be happier in the long run trying to think of something new, or at least spending your efforts on learning something new.