Is this sarcasm? I honestly can't tell. You have never experienced the expired link error? Or the 'site not available' error? HN is one of the most broken websites I frequently visit.
Also you ignored the part about tiny links. HN is full of tiny links: have you used the site on a phone and tried to upvote a post?
And thats what I mean - Craigslist is the other "broken" site that does UX well. Its not meant to be pretty or responsive - its meant to do what I expect it to do.
If pg decided to fix the broken CR/LF issue, he might be tempted to add bootstrap, and then make it responsive, and then have a feedback form. So I quite like #lazilyproductive
The User Interface is the text box, the outstanding orange/grey theme. But the experience is, upvote buttons that are too small to use well, and great insightful posts from clever informed people. Also me.
I do mean experience. Its a holistic thing.
It has "stickiness" and "retention" that all of those sites cannot dream of.
Good User Experience beats terrible. Good user experience makes money - trust us, the market will win.