News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pixel Art Tutorial by coldtea on Monday February 11, 2013 @06:37AM (#5200333)
>Certainly not me. But there's a difference between criticizing an opinion and shaming someone for holding that opinion. I also think those sorts of movies are terrible, but shaming people for enjoying them is unnecessary and immature.

Not to sure. One of the basic ways to forge a better culture is to shame people for BS choices. For example, would you let a racist (even if he doesn't hurt anyone) without shaming him? Maybe you would, I wouldn't.

>And please spare me your claims of "suffering" because Hollywood makes crappy movies.

It was meant as a humorous example, but I can defend it if you insist.

>First of all, the suffering you will cause a single person by shaming them for enjoying a movie is probably greater than the net suffering you will endure from your awareness of every bad movie you hear about in your entire life.

This takes for granted that a bad movie just stops there (at the bad cinematic experience). That is not the case. Any kind of art and entertainment, and movies in particular, shape minds, opinions, tastes etc. Bad movies have many cultural, societal and even financial results. A movie can even justify war and hatred (as any state propaganda department can attest).

Re:Pixel Art Tutorial by mistercow on Monday February 11, 2013 @09:37AM (#5200964)
>For example, would you let a racist (even if he doesn't hurt anyone) without shaming him? Maybe you would, I wouldn't.

To his face? I would tell him why his specific views were racist and harmful. Telling someone that they're racist isn't helpful. Where do they go from there? The only self-identity preserving options you've given them are to ignore you and believe that their views aren't racist (which is what usually happens), or to embrace racism as good and correct. Whereas if you get someone to reëxamine their views, you might get them to change their mind.

In fact, this is exactly what has happened with well-intended but misguided racism education. We've taught people that racism is shameful, but we haven't really taught them how to identify their own racist views. As a result, people think "Well, racist people are bad, and I'm not a bad person, so I must not be racist." And that's how you get people saying things like "I'm not racist, but I think Asians are bad drivers."

And that's the whole thing: shaming people hurts them and doesn't work. I have never changed someone's mind by making them feel bad about what they thought. I've felt self righteous for doing so, but never actually made a difference. But I have changed people's minds by engaging them in discussion. It's hard, and it's not as fun, but it sometimes works.