News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lung Cancer and the Power of Suggestion by rmc on Sunday February 10, 2013 @10:46AM (#5196668)
Were there millions of depressed people in hiding, in 1955, waiting to come out of the closet in the 1990s? Was 9.3% of the American adult population (the percentage now suffering depression) merely suffering in silence, back in 1955? Or did the drug companies and their media flacks convert a relatively rare psychological condition into a growth industry through massive advertising and media hype (in other words, through the power of suggestion)?

The author is trying to claim that many (most/majority?) cases of depression are made up and hyped. They are trying to claim that it's impossible for there to be that many actual depressed people now.

But turn it around. How many (openly) gay people/couples are there today? Millions! But there weren't that many in 1955! So what happened? Was it all media hype? <sarcasm>Or are we expected to believe that all those gay people were suffering in silence in the 1950s?!</sarcasm>.

Of course all the gay people were suffering in silence in the 50s. People don't doubt that. So why the doubt about mental illness?

Re:Lung Cancer and the Power of Suggestion by robbiep on Sunday February 10, 2013 @11:22AM (#5196792)
He also conflates bipolar with depression and anti-depression medication.

They are different conditions (albeit ones that have shaky scientific bases as 'diseases' due to the subjective nature of diagnosis).

Prozac/fluoxetine is not a prescription drug used for bipolar illness as the excess serotonin can in fact trigger manic episodes and it is thus very dangerous in bipolar patients

Re:Lung Cancer and the Power of Suggestion by tonyarkles on Sunday February 10, 2013 @11:13AM (#5196767)
I don't think that the author is trying to claim that depression is made up and hyped. What he seems to be claiming is that publicity surrounding depression could have caused an increase in the number of depressed people through the power of suggestion.

He's not saying that mental illness isn't valid, or that the people with depression aren't suffering. He's suggesting that the increase could partly be caused by the immense advertising campaigns surrounding anti-depressants; this is in no way de-legitimizing depression, just suggesting a possible cause.

Re:Lung Cancer and the Power of Suggestion by robbiep on Sunday February 10, 2013 @11:25AM (#5196798)
Except America is the only industrialised nation that allows direct marketing of antidepressants to its populace.

Other industrialised countries - Australia, the UK, France and Germany, etc have also experienced a rise in patients under treatment for these conditions, in lockstep with the US experience, despite this difference you suggest is responsible

Re:Lung Cancer and the Power of Suggestion by rmc on Sunday February 10, 2013 @01:07PM (#5197178)
It's like an experimental study that removes a confounding factor!
Re:Lung Cancer and the Power of Suggestion by rmc on Sunday February 10, 2013 @12:55PM (#5197125)
The author never outright states one way or the other whether depression was just hidden or whether it was made up by hype (or some mixture of both, or .... ). However the implication is that the media hype has made more people being diagnosed with depression.