News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by return0 on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:17AM (#5195980)
It's hard to distinguish bias from genuine preconceptions based on experience - for that one would need gender neutral data that is impossible to obtain. The reverse kind of gender bias could be found in divorce custody cases for example.

Maybe one could do an experiment in online job marketplaces: change the gender of a large number of work providers and observe how payouts change.

In any case this was a shallow and one-sided article. [But suitable for Sunday morning heated arguments over coffee and cookies]

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.174-1617.2000.t...

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405270230359240457736...

Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by crntaylor on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:40AM (#5196011)
Maybe one could do an experiment in online job marketplaces: change the gender of a large number of work providers and observe how payouts change.

Do you really think that the problem is that enough studies haven't been done?

The linked article mentions a study on the gender pay gap in academia[0], the results section of which includes

    "After 

accounting 
for [
underrepresentation of women at the full Professor level
     allocation of faculty members across departmental units, and experience]
 there

     remains 
an unexplained
 female
 pay 
disadvantage
 of 
about 
$3000.
 This
 finding 
is
     
robust 
to 
alternative 
specifications 
of
 the
 gender
 gap
 decomposition."
and later

   "... the 
female 
salary 
disadvantage 
found
 in
 the
 study
 can be
 interpreted
 as
     
a 
lower 
bound."
There is a similar study based on results from the financial industry, which if anything is even more extreme[1]



    "The gender pay gap for annual gross earnings in the sector is 60 per cent."

    "There is a gender gap of 80 per cent for performance-related pay"

    "The gender pay gap in finance sector companies cannot be explained away as a
     historical legacy. Analysis of salaries for new recruits shows that in 86 percent
     of the cases reported to us, women have lower salaries than men."

    "In 63 per cent of cases more than half of all job grades/categories exhibited a
     significant gender pay gap."

[0] http://www.facultyassociation.ubc.ca/docs/news/GenderPayEqui...

[1] http://www.equalityhumanrights.com/uploaded_files/financial_...

Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by return0 on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:41AM (#5196014)
I know there is a gender pay gap. The question is: how do we know it's not justified? Presumably the pay reflects the work done
[deleted]
Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by smsm42 on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:53AM (#5196052)
It's a huge presumption, but it's equally huge presumption that every person on the planet secretly hates women and isn't even aware of it. Either one needs proof to be called true, and neither is proven by just stating the statistics and postulating that one's favorite explanation is the right one.
Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by bromang on Sunday February 10, 2013 @06:19AM (#5196111)
This does not demonstrate any bias unless you decide that we can assume men and women with the same CV are equal in all respects
Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by andreasvc on Sunday February 10, 2013 @09:29AM (#5196470)
That's nonsense. The work of a financial executive might be quantified by how much money the company is making, but judging the output of a professor is completely subjective. Sure you can do some bean counting by looking at the number of publications and citations, but 10 years of work condensed in one paper may just be more of a contribution than 10 derivative papers, or not, it's difficult to tell without hindsight, and even then presumably lots of work is under-appreciated.

My conclusion is that we cannot with a straight face claim that we can justify such a pay gap in this case, so whether it is justified is the wrong question.

Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by ivanmilles on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:56AM (#5196059)
>how do we know it's not justified? Presumably the pay reflects the work done. Again, do you think studies haven't been done? That's the core of the discussion: pay does not reflect the work done, and it is sometimes even inverted.
Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by meredydd on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:24AM (#5195986)
I almost wish the author had included this trope too: "If I begin a conversation about sexism I am experiencing, that means that sexism against men must immediately become part of the focus of the conversation".

It's not that those issues are unimportant, but does it not strike you as strange that the very first comment doesn't discuss the content of the article directly, but does make sure to bring up sexism against men? It's not the first time this has happened, either, on HN or elsewhere.

(And, sure, this may be the first time you've brought it up. But just like the other issues she's bringing up, the "what about the men who are discriminated against?" response is a durable and ubiquitous trend. Check any other HN thread that mentions sexism if you don't believe me. It therefore becomes very annoying to people trying to have a conversation about the persistent sexism against women in technology/maths/science spaces.)

Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by smsm42 on Monday February 11, 2013 @01:46AM (#5199711)
Until this concern is taken seriously, I don't see why it should not be repeated. So far I only see it reflexively dismissed as "oh this, yet again". While the silent assumption is that only certain people and certain biases are discussed and "we are all biased" actually means only certain set of data is taken into account, and other data is dismissed as irrelevant. It's not about focus, it's about basic inclusion.

Data about gender/discipline compositions in academic disciplines: http://www.aei-ideas.org/2013/01/college-class-of-2011-by-ac...

I remember hearing a lot about sexism in disciplines which are 80+% male in this list. But I pretty much never hear about sexism in disciplines that are 80+% female.

Now, I don't make any claims here about existence or non-existence of sexism one way or another just basing on the percentage data. Maybe there is sexism in one place, maybe there is not in another, even though percentages looks the same. That's not my point here. What I am questioning is that seeing 80% on one side is universally taken alone as supporting the claim of sexism, if not proving it completely, but the same study showing the same bias to the other side is not considered the base to the same claim. I think this is related to the content of the article.

Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by return0 on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:27AM (#5195988)
No, my main point was that it's not pure bias, there might be real reasons why women get paid less and men are considered bad fathers (personally, i don't agree with both statements, but see the wsj article). I suggest, if we want to get rid of this bias, change the underlying situation that perpetuates it (e.g. not by introducing gender quotas, but by making childraising less time-consuming, or educating men to be better fathers and getting rid of ridiculous stereotypes that are perpetuated in mass culture).
Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by shardling on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:35AM (#5196003)
You have (I hope unwittingly?) just fulfilled one of the specific tropes she does mention.
Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by return0 on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:43AM (#5196018)
... And which she outright dismisses citing an irrelevant study. (I did mention it's a poor article, didn't i?)

  When we talk about real-life statistical evidence, that’s  
  not conclusive, either, because all differences are   
  explained by women having babies, other priorities, etc 
 (Except they’re not, as the linked document explains very clearly.)
The linked document is a report with some recommendations about how to measure pay gap

Btw, can someone explain the usage of the word "trope" here?

Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by shardling on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:47AM (#5196036)
A trope is a recurring theme. In this context, it refers to highly predictable responses to particular arguments.

I don't think the post was super well written, but I also don't see how the cited study was irrelevant -- it shows the existence of a gender bias that operates completely independently of the choices of any individual woman:

http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/2012/09/19/...

Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by fhars on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:45AM (#5196032)
If you actually had read the linked "shallow" article, you would have noticed that the author cited exactly the kind of study you want to see. In the very first paragraph.
Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by return0 on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:54AM (#5196056)
That's not the kind of study i meant. We need a way to observe whether men deserve to be paid more because they work more or not.
Re:Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians by ivanmilles on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:57AM (#5196061)
...if they work more /as evaluated by men/.