Re:For sale: Trusted root SSL CA signing certificate
by rmhrisk on Saturday February 09, 2013 @09:02PM
(#5195089)
Marsh, I understand your concern and I share it though I don't agree with the conclusion (re sticking head in the ground).
With that said GlobalSign has committed to implementing CT and we hope all other CAs agree to do the same as Adam points out earlier in this thread its the way to bring the desired transperancy.
That said it alone inst enough either, to start we also need TACK (and/or HSTS pinning), CAA, robust revocation checking and Name Constraints.
And while conversations like this are uncomfortable (certainly for me being on the receiving end) I think they help too.
Re:For sale: Trusted root SSL CA signing certificate
by marshray on Saturday February 09, 2013 @09:38PM
(#5195183)
So are you proposing that 3rd party sub-CAs be brought under public CT?
I could get on board with that.
Re:For sale: Trusted root SSL CA signing certificate
by rmhrisk on Saturday February 09, 2013 @09:51PM
(#5195214)
I believe for CT to "work" all CAs on the public internet need to participate.
I also believe that certificate transparency by itself is insufficient and the other items I mentioned are also needed.
This is not directed specifically at you @rmhrisk, but it's really disappointing how everyone involved in PKI seems to have a systematic habit of pretending like clearly identified potential risks and vulnerabilities are equivalent to impossible until (and sometimes even after) they're actually caught being used in an actual exploit.