News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by InclinedPlane on Saturday February 09, 2013 @12:17AM (#5191790)
Wow, the sheer quantity of unhelpful advice in this thread is simply mind boggling. Hey, let's all hate paypal because they "steal" people's money. Ignoring the seriously thorny legal bramble that the OP has run headlong into with nary a concern. There is a bounteous variety of comments of the form "Paypal sux! {Use X instead!}" Where X may be stripe, or wepay, or whatever. Ignoring the fact that stripe wouldn't help in this case (it's US only), if you go read the terms of service of stripe or wepay you'll find exactly the same things there as are at issue here. You'll need an SSN or EID or tax ID with stripe too, just as you would with a WePay business account. There's a reason for that, and it has to do with the law.

There are maybe only half a dozen reasonable, substantially helpful, and actionable replies in this whole thread (which would put it at maybe a 4% SNR), almost all the rest is useless. If this is what HN is going to be, I don't want it.

As for my advice, it's simple. Go talk to a lawyer as soon as possible, you have a lot of issues that need sorting and a good lawyer is absolutely necessary to get through those issues, and they'll help to put you on the right footing to deal with paypal. It sucks that you have been acting in good faith and doing good work and have gotten tangled in the mess that is the many layers of laws, regulations, and corporate policies that make up our modern immigration, taxation, and financial systems. You have my sympathies for that and I wish you the best of luck, hopefully you'll be able to keep the proceeds of your excellent work without any serious negative repercussions.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by winter_blue on Saturday February 09, 2013 @01:00AM (#5191871)
I've replied with some very practical advice relating to OP's specific situation (F-1 student) here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5191832

(Sorry if this sounds like I'm promoting it or anything. I just don't want my comment to get buried among the 150+ other comments here.)

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by wyuenho on Saturday February 09, 2013 @03:19AM (#5192097)
I used to be an international student in the US. So I feel OP's pain. I have an advice in addition to winter_blue's. However, I have been out of the US for 3 years and I don't know if any rules have changed since then.

Besides applying for precompletion OPT which will take months and months, a much quicker route for me was to get a part-time job at school. I did this when I was working as a CS tutor in my CS department's lab. This could still be possible for international students, it's definitely worth checking right row. The reason a social security card or a tax ID is needed for international student is solely for tax purposes. Yes, you read it right, we pay sales tax and income tax and don't get to vote or a path to citizenship in less then 20 years. I suspect your funds were frozen because PayPal could not determine whether your money should be considered income or something else. If it's income, you'll have to pay taxes.

I don't know which school you go to, but generally there should be hundreds of part-time jobs in all sorts of variety available at your school to accommodate students in work-study programs. You can apply for a job to be a lab janitor in a day and get your SS card in less than about 2 weeks. Once you have that then you can file a dispute complaint with PayPal.

Good Luck.

---Additional Advice Here After Edit---

If your 200k is saved towards paying for your tuition and living expenses, and you have money problem now, you should talk to your school's international student's office and/or legal counsel immediately. You might be allowed to work off-campus and stay in school under the premise that you are in "economic hardship".

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by winter_blue on Saturday February 09, 2013 @04:06AM (#5192170)
This is a bad idea. Getting an SSN does not solve the bigger issue of work authorization. Having an SSN would make Paypal happy, but he could be deported by SEVIS/USCIS/ICE for earning an income without proper work authorization.

F-1 OPT is the only status I know that allows you to earn an income while being self-employed.

Even on an H-1B doing what the OP did would be a violation of status, and could lead to deportation.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by wyuenho on Saturday February 09, 2013 @04:50AM (#5192212)

    Getting an SSN does not solve the bigger issue of work authorization.
That's right, but I didn't say getting an SSN will get you a work authorization. As an international student, you are legally allowed to be employed on-campus[1] on a part-time basis provided that you maintain your student status, which basically means you have an above minimum GPA and not serving any academic disciplinary actions. In order to get a permission to work on-campus, you need to file an I-9 form, then get an SSN, then you can start working, but you can get a job on-campus before any of these happens, as long as you don't get paid before you have I-9 filled out, authorized by CEVIS and have an SSN.

    F-1 OPT is the only status I know that allows you to earn an income while being self-employed.
Generally, that's impossible, unless you incorporate a sole-proprietorship, which is generally not possible unless you change your VISA status to O-1 (alien with extraordinary abilities) or EB-5 (investor with 500K - 1 mil in the bank) or some other forms of partnerships with a citizen, and apply for an H-1 for yourself through the company. You are required to pay income taxes if you are "employed" or have any kind of income. You cannot show that information if you don't have the proper paperwork, and you can't have those paperwork unless you are employed under an organization that can issue you work-authorization.

[1]: http://www.bu.edu/isso/students/current/f1/employment/on-cam...

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by winter_blue on Saturday February 09, 2013 @09:05AM (#5192541)
I'm not sure what you're point here is.

Yes, getting an SSN is easy (just find an on-campus job), but cashing out the $200k could lead to the OP being deported for earning an income without proper work authorization.

If you get an SSN, you are still only allowed to receive an income from authorized jobs/sources. On-campus jobs are one of them. But a self-run online business, does not count as one -- unless you get it authorized via OPT (or some other means.)

> Generally, that's impossible

It is indeed possible to work for your own company while on F-1 OPT status. I've explained it in detail on this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5191832 (which I referred to in the grandparent comment).

I should add, "incorporate a sole-proprietorship" is a non sequitur. The term "incorporate" by definition describes the act of forming a corporation. A sole-proprietorship is when you operate a business on your own name, and not under a company's name. It does not give you the "liability shield" that a corporation or LLC provides, and is generally a bad idea for most businesses.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by wyuenho on Saturday February 09, 2013 @10:07AM (#5192708)
I'm sorry I've missed your point too, let's say he against all odds now magically got a pre-completion OPT authorized (which takes A LOT OF persuasion of the school officials BTW), an EAD, and have enough money to get a lawyer and incorporate a C-corp or what have you, before Immigration gets to him, now what? He still violated the rules to maintain his visa status.

If indeed he is in danger of being deported, how is ANY of your suggested action going to save him? He's running against time here, he can try to change his visa status, which Uncle Sam could find out about this and deny by the way. But if he was successful, Immigration could still decide to immediate terminate his visa when they find out about this. He is under risk of being deported, whatever he does now might alert Immigration, which puts him under further risk of being deported. I'm sorry I've totally missed your point here, but wouldn't minimizing damage the best course of action under these circumstances? What's the best way to minimize damage? Oh right, getting his money back, transfer it out of the country and hope Uncle Sam doesn't find out, or do absolutely nothing and hope Uncle Sam doesn't find out and still have money to go to school.

OP said he's from Venezuela, did you hear they just decided to devalue their currency by a third? Assuming he doesn't get his money back, his family suddenly has to pay 150% of tuition before devaluation for him to stay in school in the US. I don't know about his financial situation, but sounds like a lot of burden to me. Tuition and living expenses for international students currently range in about $100K a year. Minimizing damage sounds like the best course of action here.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by cheapsteak on Friday February 15, 2013 @09:19AM (#5226234)
>Even on an H-1B doing what the OP did would be a violation of status

Could you expand on this? Do you mean an H-1B doesn't let you sell things online?

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by neltnerb on Saturday February 09, 2013 @01:20AM (#5191907)
I'm no lawyer, but I bet the issue is that the US will want him to pay taxes on that income and has no way to do so at present.

http://www.irs.gov/Individuals/International-Taxpayers/Taxpa...

Perhaps the obvious answer is to find a way to convince the government to let him pay the $50,600 in taxes he would owe on that $200k of income if he were a citizen with a SSN...

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by chris_wot on Saturday February 09, 2013 @06:43AM (#5192344)
Isn't that the job of the IRS? What does PayPal have to do with that?
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by rschmitty on Saturday February 09, 2013 @07:41AM (#5192416)
Paypal has to report these things over a certain amount
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by lawnchair_larry on Saturday February 09, 2013 @01:23PM (#5193349)
But they don't have to police it. And they shouldn't.
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by JohnHaugeland on Saturday February 09, 2013 @08:04PM (#5194892)
Sorry, did you just suggest that a payment processor should not be required to ensure that when they hand money out, it's done legally?
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by chris_wot on Sunday February 10, 2013 @03:39AM (#5195832)
There's a vast difference between reporting and freezing. Besides which, if I pay my taxes, in no way will PayPal ever be involved.
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by JohnHaugeland on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:19PM (#5198208)
> There's a vast difference between reporting and freezing.

Yes, there is. For example, one is legal in this situation, and the other isn't. So, I'm still a little confused.

Is your position that PayPal should illegally pay money out, then report it?

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by chris_wot on Monday February 11, 2013 @03:28AM (#5199920)
It is not my position, in fact it's not even relevant to the issue that's being discussed. The original poster said that "the US will want him to pay taxes on that income and has no way to do so at present", so are therefore making PayPal collect on their behalf by freezing their funds.

My position is that it's not PayPal's role to freeze accounts without the specific guidance of the IRS. It's also not PayPal's business how the individual pays his taxes - he may decide to take the entire amount out of the account and then pay it in cash to the IRS. It's not up to PayPal to freeze the entire sum of money because the IRS wants their cut.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by chris_wot on Saturday February 09, 2013 @04:57PM (#5194176)
I don't know why you got down voted, I'd be interested hearing why that person disagreed with you!
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by chris_wot on Saturday February 09, 2013 @06:42AM (#5192341)
What, so PayPal allowed him to use their service with a Social Security number, then they take his money because he doesn't have one?

PayPal is the one at fault here. Don't let someone use your service without adequate ID. Tell them and require it before you can use the service.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by scorpion032 on Saturday February 09, 2013 @07:16AM (#5192387)
You can deposit the funds without any tax details or linking any bank account. But you cannot withdraw it without one.

If transferring money without SSN is illegal; I wonder how collecting it without one would be legal.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by JohnHaugeland on Saturday February 09, 2013 @08:01PM (#5194879)
Transferring under $600 a year without an SSN is entirely legal. That's money considered too small to be worth taxing.

One place an American can usually quite easily check this is at your local gambling area. They are locked by the same rules. If you win big at the horse races, you don't get to take your money until you fill out tax paperwork.

This is no different, except that OP is international, and didn't know our rules as a result.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by chris_wot on Saturday February 09, 2013 @08:00AM (#5192440)
Then PayPal should make this very, very clear. In fact, I'd go further: they should mandate that you provide an SSN before you can collect money. It's unethical to do otherwise: anyone who uses PayPal to collect money will want to withdraw it.
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by JohnHaugeland on Saturday February 09, 2013 @08:03PM (#5194888)
One, PayPal does make their rules very clear. It isn't PayPal's fault that its users don't bother to read the rules.

Two, these rules do not come from PayPal; they come from the US Federal Government.

Three, the thing you're saying they should make clear is something someone else guessed about, and it's not correct. As long as the number is under $600 a year, there's no paperwork required.

I don't understand why we're all panicking so hard about a set of guesses that people have made. If you just think the situation over a little bit, it's pretty obvious that what's really going on is OP hasn't finished his free tax paperwork, and that PayPal can't hand out money until the tax situation is made legal.

And when you look at it that way, PayPal is actually doing exactly the right thing.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by chris_wot on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @03:06AM (#5211951)
Yet they asked him for his SSN. They didn't ask for him to fill in his "tax paperwork".

I'm very interested in what tax laws you believe he's broken though.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by jaredstenquist on Saturday February 09, 2013 @11:19AM (#5192926)
Paypal has no incentive here. They can just float the cash and earn a small % on it. Do it to enough people and you understand how they make a lot of money.
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by im3w1l on Saturday February 09, 2013 @05:55PM (#5194451)
They're killing their brand with badwill though.
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by JohnHaugeland on Saturday February 09, 2013 @07:59PM (#5194872)
> What, so PayPal allowed him to use their service with a Social Security number, then they take his money because he doesn't have one?

No. You don't need an SSN as long as it's less than $600 a year. This was correct.

His money hasn't been taken; they just won't disburse it until he does his free paperwork, as required by the US Government. That's entirely legitimate.

.

> PayPal is the one at fault here. Don't let someone use your service without adequate ID.

They did not. When OP does the rest of what he's supposed to do, he's going to have his money unlocked.

PayPal is being as liberal, correctly, as the law permits.

.

> Tell them and require it before you can use the service.

Yeah, they did. Maybe you should read the user agreement of a system before using it to collect nearly a quarter million dollars internationally. It's only three pages.

There is a point at which OP had a responsibility, too.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by n3rdy on Sunday February 10, 2013 @04:25AM (#5195909)
> His money hasn't been taken; they just won't disburse it until he does his free paperwork, as required by the US Government. That's entirely legitimate.

Half of it will be taken by the U.S government, that's likely the reason his paypal account got locked.

There is nothing legitimate about theft, whether its paypal or the IRS stealing his money.

> Yeah, they did. Maybe you should read the user agreement of a system before using it to collect nearly a quarter million dollars internationally. It's only three pages. There is a point at which OP had a responsibility, too.

He earned that quarter million dollars providing a service other people found useful. There is no justification for any organization or government to take any of it away from him.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by JohnHaugeland on Sunday February 10, 2013 @05:20PM (#5198218)
>Half of it will be taken by the U.S government, that's likely the reason his paypal account got locked.

Yes, that's called taxes. There's nothing wrong with that. Also, the correct number is likely quite a bit lower.

Venezuela's going to take more than the US does.

.

> There is nothing legitimate about theft, whether its paypal or the IRS stealing his money.

It's really hard to take you seriously when you pretend that taxes are theft, and that the IRS is stealing.

.

> There is no justification for any organization or government to take any of it away from him.

Uh huh.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by chris_wot on Monday February 11, 2013 @03:36AM (#5199933)
>Yes, that's called taxes. There's nothing wrong with that. Also, the correct number is likely quite a bit lower.

Taxes are usually filed by a specific time. Taxes are not taken at an arbitrary time, after an arbitrary amount of money is collected. Which appears to be what is happening here.

It seems to me that all this talk about taxes is wrong - it sounds like PayPal's insane money laundering hair trigger got invoked, and they froze the money. Now they are asking for paperwork or ID (a Social Security Number) that cannot be provided because the one who collected the money is not a U.S. citizen.

That's holding the man over a barrel.

Please count me out of any talk that taxes are illegal though. That's about the most ridiculous position anyone can take.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by n3rdy on Sunday February 10, 2013 @10:44PM (#5199260)
> Yes, that's called taxes. There's nothing wrong with that.

Of course there is.

> It's really hard to take you seriously when you pretend that taxes are theft, and that the IRS is stealing.

It's hard to take me seriously because I assert that its theft when one group of people threatens another with violence unless they give them their money?

What gives governments the right to take whatever they want from anybody?

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by deepakjnath on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @12:02AM (#5205267)
Looking at taxes as a partnership is more appropriate. The government sets up systems that help you make a good business, for example a good financial system, a good law and order system, good infrastructure etc. These things help you make the money. So the government is a partner with anyone who uses these infrastructure to make money and in this partnership there is a sharing of profit which can be understood as taxes.
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by n3rdy on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @07:10AM (#5206293)
That would be fine if it were voluntary. But you cannot opt out. If you try to opt out, you go to jail.

I didn't ask the government to do any of that for me, and I would prefer they didn't. I can't fix someones car without telling them, and then demand payment.

Our government has done a terrible job at infrastructure and I hardly find it unreasonable to believe that I should be allowed to hire people I choose for my needs.

If I wanted an exciting life full of collapsing bridges, sinkholes, and trigger happy police, I would gladly hire government. I'm dull though. I prefer things to work the way I expect them to, no surprises for me please.

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by stqbert on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @05:12PM (#5209948)
You can opt out. Renounce your citizenship.
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by n3rdy on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @07:33PM (#5210569)
Do you think its reasonable that government takes less from you if you commit suicide than if you renounce your citizenship?

I never agreed to be a citizen in the first place. Why should anyone have to give up everything they have just because the government decided to auto enroll them into a system without their consent?

Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by chris_wot on Wednesday February 13, 2013 @03:02AM (#5211947)
You didn't ask to be born. Humanity has done an absolutely terrible job of managing this planet. It's not fair that people have no say about being born into it.
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by crypto_cat on Tuesday February 12, 2013 @03:59AM (#5205850)
Only a very small fraction of tax revenues are applied toward this helpful infrastructure. The majority is used to fund useless wars and other special interest groups - hardly a mutual partnership.
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by ig1 on Saturday February 09, 2013 @04:17PM (#5194041)
They won't keep his money in any case, they'll either hold it until the buyers can no-longer reverse the charges (at which point they'll release it to the OP and close his account) or they'll refund it to the people who paid into the account.
Re:I made $200K and PayPal locked my account by zopticity on Saturday February 09, 2013 @05:09AM (#5192236)
You definitely should use WePay since it's FDIC insured.