I agreed. Harry can't talk about a Monoid with that non well-defined function. He deserved to be fired :D
(As I pointed out in my comment: http://www.jasq.org/2/post/2013/01/the-mathematician-the-mon...)
If Dick is a systems programmer, his code would look pretty much exactly like Harry's, except he'd call it a priority queue of capacity 1.
And he'd have written it over breakfast, while Harry was still pondering the side problem of analytically defining the volume of his bath tub :)
Re:Tom, Dick & Harry
by jQueryIsAwesome on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @09:47PM
(#5180198)
> You'd think a reasonable math person--or any halfway competent programmer--would not throw in a call to math.random in the definition of their monoid!
Yeah, just pick 'a'; if he was in the database before 'b' chances are that he is the one who has been with the company for the longest time; and if that's a lie then is just as random as math.random anyway.
Anyhow, if we're playing at parables, chances are Harry took advantage of the job market and his knowledge and went to work for a trading shop or hedge fund, making more money than any developer at the old company (150,000, really?) and not being hated for knowing stuff. And hopefully using a nicer language like Haskell or OCaml.
Also, if Dick's a "systems" programmer, chances are his code would actually be written in C, longer than the monoid Scala code and harder to read. It would be fast though.