Ask HN: For a simple forum, should I use bbPress or is there a HN/reddit style one?
I'm thinking of starting a discussion forum over at my Gifty.co.nz website. I've never liked heavy and ugly phpBB-style forums. I'm really keen on simple and minimalist, so I like bbPress. And PunBB looks okay.
But something with the simplicity and threadedness of Hacker News or reddit would really be great.
Does anyone have any ideas or experience?
(
16 comments
| 21 points
| on HN
)
They're both open source and you could alter it so that submissions couldn't be links if you so chose.
http://arclanguage.org/ http://code.reddit.com/
reddit is a possibility, because I know Python, but I felt it was quite large-scale. Maybe I should look at the code properly, though. Thanks!
Rolling something from the HN or Reddit codebase sounds like a pretty interesting project, though.
http://getvanilla.com/
You might also look into whether http://intensedebate.com/ would work for your purposes...it does have threading and voting.
Finally if you or your developer(s) know Python/Django, you could check out the following two Django plugins:
http://code.google.com/p/django-threadedcomments/ http://code.google.com/p/django-voting/
You could pretty easily put together a threaded, votable discussion thread based on these. (In fact, you can find a whole lot of other social networking features in Pinax, which I'd describe as a social networking framework for Django: http://code.google.com/p/django-hotclub/)
Hope some of these suggestions are helpful.
board.vivalavinyl.org board.crewcial.org
Here's the source http://code.google.com/p/pgboard/
It's actually a lot like HN.
If it's an interesting question, it will get voted up, probably.