News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:USPS to Cut Saturday Mail by therobot24 on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @10:24AM (#5176785)
USPS cannot go away because FedEx/DHS/UPS have no obligation to deliver to po-dunk-town, Montana where it would be infeasible for them to put it on their route. While USPS guarantees mail to small, forgotten areas.
Re:USPS to Cut Saturday Mail by robomartin on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @12:40PM (#5177711)
> USPS cannot go away because FedEx/DHS/UPS have no obligation to deliver to po-dunk-town, Montana

Who cares? Really. You are talking about keeping alive an organization that is now beyond obsolete just because people choose to live in these places? It's their choice. Their problem. Why is it my responsibility to subsidize people who choose to live in places that are challenged in more than one way?

I don't have any problem with people living in the middle of a desert if they want to. Or 3,000 feet up a mountain in a cabin that is only reachable via helicopter and has no roads in or out. That's fine. As far as I am concerned, you are free to do as you wish and live wherever you want to.

That said, it is YOUR responsibility to live with the consequences of the choices you have made in life. If this means that you have to drive twenty miles to pick-up your mail once a week, or pay for a helicopter to deliver mail and supplies, so be it. Your choice. You don't have to live there. Don't make it my responsibility. It isn't.

Re:USPS to Cut Saturday Mail by Turing_Machine on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @12:52PM (#5177770)
Interesting theory.

Why don't we take it to its logical conclusion and remove all services for anyone who doesn't live in Washington, DC?

Re:USPS to Cut Saturday Mail by robomartin on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @01:00PM (#5177819)
How can that possibly be a logical conclusion? Are you just being funny?
Re:USPS to Cut Saturday Mail by Turing_Machine on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @03:38PM (#5178661)
Your argument is that providing government services to outlying regions isn't justified because those people "chose to live there".

You (presumably) chose to live somewhere other than Washington D.C.

The exact same argument applies.

Re:USPS to Cut Saturday Mail by robomartin on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @06:42PM (#5179657)
How can I possibly argue with that kind of logic?
Re:USPS to Cut Saturday Mail by cookiecaper on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @06:00PM (#5179464)
His argument is that we shouldn't feel obliged to deliver mail to residences so far out of the way that said delivery is cost prohibitive, not that "no government services should be provided to anyone not in Washington DC". Sounds reasonable to me. The specifics of "cost prohibitive" and "out of the way" can be refined to prevent ideologically-charged, unrealistic reductions like yours.
Re:USPS to Cut Saturday Mail by Turing_Machine on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @08:05PM (#5179922)
"His argument is that we shouldn't feel obliged to deliver mail to residences so far out of the way that said delivery is cost prohibitive"

Define "cost prohibitive". Costs exceed revenue for that particular piece? If so, I can guarantee you that the delivery radius is a lot smaller than you (and he) appear to think that it is.

There's a reason why essentially every country adopted a flat-rate fee for regular mail way back in the 19th century.

Re:USPS to Cut Saturday Mail by therobot24 on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @10:56PM (#5180436)
where do you draw the line? Today it's infeasible for po-dunk-town, Montana, tomorrow it's anywhere more than 5 miles from the nearest city. Yes that's hyperbole, but it illustrates the point that what's infeasible is relative to the time. I'm sure the pony express wasn't exactly feasible, but it was still necessary.

"Why is it my responsibility to subsidize people who choose to live in places that are challenged in more than one way?"

What can be more selfish - the fact that you only care about the situation you're in, or the fact that you'd leave others out to dry because you feel like you're paying for something you wouldn't do. Those who live in po-dunk-town, Montana are part of the US just as you are, and frankly deserve to have their mail delivered as well.