Re:Have we given up too quickly on non-overlapping window GUIs?
by amichail on Sunday March 15, 2009 @10:28PM
(#517639)
Why allow window overlap at all in mac/win?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Have we given up too quickly on non-overlapping window GUIs?
by nostrademons on Sunday March 15, 2009 @11:02PM
(#517669)
Because some people really like it. I always feel claustrophobic in tiling window managers, for example.
There is a significant geek population that likes tiling WMs. More power to 'em. But I think the general public probably like the freedom to overlap windows as they see fit.
Re:Have we given up too quickly on non-overlapping window GUIs?
by pmarin on Monday March 16, 2009 @03:08AM
(#517865)
The moderm tiling WMs (DWM/awesome/xmonad) allow you to use a dinamic layout (overlapping) if you want.
Re:Have we given up too quickly on non-overlapping window GUIs?
by amichail on Sunday March 15, 2009 @11:05PM
(#517672)
Is there a usability advantage to overlapping windows?
Re:Have we given up too quickly on non-overlapping window GUIs?
by unalone on Sunday March 15, 2009 @11:36PM
(#517696)
My immediate response is that yes, there is, because it preserves the physical feeling that I have. That is to say, my windows go where I want them to go. That's control that I like.
The other response is that there is because you can hide things you aren't using behind other windows. Right now, the 4 windows I have open wouldn't all fit on a single screen without overlapping.