News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unpacking my knapsack: the privileges of a Hispanic male ... by aptwebapps on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @04:05AM (#5175555)
I don't have a problem with physics, I just think that applying this level of determinism to human interactions is useless. And as I said, if you have completely internalized that yourself, how is it that you are question other people's behavior? It is, after all, predetermined.

To put it another way, it's like trying to fix a watch with a shotgun. And as long as you would like to keep the watch, I'd say save the shotgun for other uses.

Pure determinism is fun to play with, and you can believe that it is the ultimate answer, but it has no real use here and now.

This is separate to my main point, but I like this quote from E. F. Schumacher: "Relativism and positivism, of course, are purely metaphysical doctrines with the peculiar and ironical distinction that they deny the validity of all metaphysics. including themselves."

Re:Unpacking my knapsack: the privileges of a Hispanic male ... by confluence on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @04:12AM (#5175571)
I never said absolute determinism (notice the randomness in the line).

You took down a straw man.

Re:Unpacking my knapsack: the privileges of a Hispanic male ... by aptwebapps on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @04:19AM (#5175586)
You didn't have it in the previous post in which you said this:

"Finally, physics eliminates the case for free will. So yes - you do what you do because you were set up to do it."

Also, for the purposes of my argument randomness doesn't really matter, anyway. It's whether you exclude free will or not.