Re:Unpacking my knapsack: the privileges of a Hispanic male ...
by r00fus on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @02:43PM
(#5178361)
Point being, a whole lot of what makes you "you" is completely not in your hands. Not free will. I didn't choose to get born.
To dictate policies that advocate punishing and killing people for what they had no control over (like being born in a muslim-majority country) is folly, or worse - a justification for bad behavior.
Re:Unpacking my knapsack: the privileges of a Hispanic male ...
by confluence on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @03:41AM
(#5175496)
The point of that sentence was to indicate two things. Firstly your existence is random. Secondly - you are wholly the product of your arbitrary environment. That is all.
This is an information free sentence. Everything that makes me _me_ comes from my genes and my environment. If it were much different, I wouldn't be me. If you are attributing everything I do to an external force even though it goes through the intermediate step of my identity and skills in the process, then you just have a tautological statement. Sure, things happen because things happen. Bravo, but I'm also one of those things.