Re:The NFL’s problems in one accidentally revealing ad
by jamesaguilar on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @05:14PM
(#5173647)
Is this really true? Those videos of old minimally padded players still look like there is substantially more violent tackling going on than what we see in those other sports.
Re:The NFL’s problems in one accidentally revealing ad
by snowwrestler on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @05:20PM
(#5173673)
It's not true. The padding and helmets in U.S. football did not appear out of nowhere; they were added to the game to increase safety. The game was less safe without them.
This is a good example of "Chesterton's Fence." If you find a fence across a road, it might seem like a good idea to tear it down. But the fence did not appear there by itself--someone built it there on purpose. So maybe it would be smart to understand why it was built in the first place before proposing to tear it down.
Re:The NFL’s problems in one accidentally revealing ad
by mieubrisse on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @05:31PM
(#5173743)
A valid point, but I think we can also say that when helmets were added to football, they were thinking about preventing concussions and weren't aware of the potentially more lethal effects of chronic trauma. Now that we have seen both sides, we can make a more educated decision on the subject.
In the absence of padding and helmets this would be rare in American football as well. Oh sure players would run toward each other. But the results would be a rugby-style wrap-arms-and-pull-down tackle rather than an NFL-style airborne earhole clock-cleaning.
I agree with most of your other points; the NFL may well be safer now than at any time in the modern era. I doubt it will ever be safe, however.