I've seen a couple of air-blade installations, and in those they have slowed things down because paper towel dispensers allow you to take a towel, step back, and dry your hands while another person gets a towel. Rolling towels (ones where the towel is on a continuous loop) have the same issue of one user at a time.
On the other hand ever every faucet was also a drying station you've basically upped the number of drying stations tremendously and that is a win for speed.
Side benefits of keeping water off the sink/floor are good.
I wonder if we'll ever see anyone taking this to the extreme of stalls with only water and air tools for washing up (Japanese style toilets for wiping, local air-taps for your hands).
I largely agree with your points, but I wanted to point out that most modern bathrooms(and certainly not bathrooms that may have this device deployed) don't have paper towel dispensers. So it isn't a question of paper towels vs this technology, but this technology vs the hot air fan, or the dyson air blade, or other similar non-dead-tree tech
What's keeping the air from blowing droplets of water from the sink to my shirt or face?
Many people don't dry their hands at all in a public bath room (that's what god invented jazz hands[1] for).
By combining faucet and dryer you force these people into the same bottleneck as the hand-dryer users.
Wow, great point. You're obviously unbiased! You don't even know the details of the simulation, but you're confident that you really know what's up based on your presence in "the real world".
> Many people don't dry their hands at all in a public bath room
Yes, but they still wash their hands. Many people don't dry their hands because they have to use the hot air blowers, which they know are ineffective. If they see an effective device, some members of that group will choose to use it instead of jazz handing. But even discounting those people, the wash + dry combination still works out better for most cases I can devise. The only universe I have come up with where wash and then dry else where is better than washing and drying at the same station is if there are an equal number of paper towel dispensers as there are to sinks, which has never happened in a bathroom where the number of sinks > 2, as far as I know.
> By combining faucet and dryer you force these people into the same bottleneck as the hand-dryer users.
I wasn't arguing for optimizing any one special interest groups time spent in the bathroom, I was optimizing for the total network throughput of the bathroom.
But you didn't. You have serialized access to two resources that were previously independent.
Since a significant portion of users need only one of the two resources you have created a new point of contention. For access to the faucet not only do I have to wait for people washing their hands, now I also have to wait for people drying their hands.
Those are the only scenarios where your argument holds, however.
Simply put, you are moving from 2 independent operations to 2 mutually exclusive operations – meaning that 1 sink (in the Dyson case) can only service 1 user at a time vs 1 sink+1 dryer/towel dispenser which can, at a minimum, service 2 users at once (there's actually a much bigger set of time/path calculations that could go in to this, but the simple case is enough to make it clear that your thinking is confused on this.)
With one exception, every bathroom within my memory had the drier as a bottleneck, typically at a ratio of 3:1 or worse.
Having a drier per sink would actually improve the efficiency.
The one exception was a older building which had towel dispensers over each of 5 sinks. They eventually replaced them with a single dispenser on the wall at the end of the row. Problem was, towels would inevitably fall in the sink and cause a clog.
Exactly. Sinks seem to always outnumber dryers by a wide margin.
I soap, wash, shake and wipe my hands in my pockets as I walk out the door if I'm in a hurry.
Actually, I guess separating the towel dispensers and trash cans in existing bathrooms would be a smart efficiency move since it would encourage people to grab a towel and keep moving.
Or am I missing something here?
Suppose there's a sink that washes and dries, and there are two people who want to use it. The second person will spend 30 seconds waiting, and 30 seconds washing/drying. So, 60 sec total.
If there's a sink and a separate dryer, the second person will spend 15 sec waiting, 15 sec washing, and 15 sec drying. So, 45 sec total. The second person gets a 15 seconds savings, because he can start washing as soon as the first person finishes washing, rather than having to "block" until the first person is done washing and drying.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pipeline_(computing)#Concept_an...
1 sink and 1 dryer: first person leaves after 30s, after 60s 3 people have been served.
2 sink and dryer combos: 2 people leaves after 30s, after 60s 4 people have been served.
I think the analog is that parallel processing is better than pipelining.
Because typical bathrooms have 4 times as many sinks as they have hand driers, and I still see sink lines more often than drier lines.
In general (at least in the US) drying takes far longer than washing. Because most people wash quickly/poorly whereas driers are on timers and most are horrible.
And when your hands are still wet even after negotiating the unresponsive sensor and waiting an entire drying duration, it's understandable that many people would just as soon skip it.
That is, unless it's like another place I know of where there's a paper towel dispenser and trash slot between every sink, in which case this faucet wouldn't change anything - they'd just be using their sink instead of standing in front of it with a paper towel.
Of course, most public restrooms have fewer drying stations than sinks, so this would probably be less of an issue.
Side note: As a man, I think the last time I had to wait to dry my hands was half time at a sports stadium, and even then it was only a 20 second wait.
See, by splitting up washing and drying into two steps, you allow two people to be in the process of cleaning their hands at a time.
By bundling the two steps together, you reduce the amount of stuff in the bathroom, but you also reduce the efficiency of the bathroom.
This AirBlade Faucet is a great idea for low-usage bathrooms: less paper towels, less equipment to maintain, etc. For high-volume bathrooms, (airports, etc) this would actually be a step backwards to put these faucets in, if a goal of the bathroom is to be able to quickly serve a large group of people.