Re:Hat, not CAP: Introducing Highly Available Transactions
by prodigal_erik on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @05:23PM
(#5173692)
> matching the weak isolation provided by many databases, hopefully provide a familiar programming interface
I'm not sure it's really that familiar. Just knowing how to make requests doesn't ensure you really understand all the ways the answers could be wrong, much less have done the analysis and proven you can withstand all those failure modes. I think a lot of systems out there are quietly corrupting themselves in ways the maintainers didn't have high enough scale or good enough analytics to notice, at least not early enough to recover to a valid state.
As I tried to stress in the post, we aren't claiming to "beat CAP" or provide "100% ACID compliance"; we're attempting to strengthen the semantic limits of highly available systems. I intended "HAT, not CAP" as a play on acronyms, not as a claim to achieve the impossible.
edit: We're also certainly not claiming to have a "CA" solution, whatever that means. There's a lot of confusion between "CAP atomicity"==linearizability and "ACID atomicity"=="transactional atomicity"/"all or nothing"; see http://www.bailis.org/blog/hat-not-cap-introducing-highly-av...