News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US diplomat: If EU allows 'right to be forgotten' …it mig... by danso on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @08:07AM (#5170430)
From the OP: Under the draft Regulation individuals would enjoy a qualified 'right to be forgotten'. That right would enable them to force organisations to delete personal data stored about them "without delay". Organisations that have made the data public would be liable for the data published by third parties and would be required to "take all reasonable steps, including technical measures" to inform those groups to delete the information.

Talk about a blow to the First Amendment. Let's give it the benefit of the doubt and say that this law doesn't force news sites to remove old stories from the web that identify people.

According to the OP's interpretation, if someone uses Twitter to tweet something racist/sexist/utterly despicable and then deletes it after getting called out on it, that person could sue Twitter ten years later if I happened to reply and quote that Tweet? Or if I referenced it in a blog post? And Twitter would be expected to take any technical means necessary to silence me?

How is this law not the SOPA of information?

Re:US diplomat: If EU allows 'right to be forgotten' …it mig... by noahc on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @08:21AM (#5170479)
Doesn't _Organisations would be able to oppose the deletion of information if they could show they have a right to publish the data under the fundamental principle of freedom of expression or if it is in the public interest for the data to remain in existence._ take care of it?

It wouldn't be hard to argue that that tweet serves the public interest by allowing the sunlight to shine on it in public.

Obviously this is a Register article so it's light on details, but it seems to me that this is targeted at organizations and you send them a message that says, "delete everything about me" ie a collection of data, not "delete this one thing about me" ie a member of data. How that is codified into law is unclear.

Re:US diplomat: If EU allows 'right to be forgotten' …it mig... by danso on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @08:35AM (#5170534)
So this is where you and I disagree. You are seeing this as "well, ideally, the law would be seen this way" and I'm thinking, "well, this is how lawyers will try to interpret the law to bring litigation forward"

We aren't ideologically opposed, we have different pragmatic expectations.

Re:US diplomat: If EU allows 'right to be forgotten' …it mig... by rbehrends on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @09:06AM (#5170669)
Read article 17 (3) of the draft regulation [1]:

The controller shall carry out the erasure without delay, except to the extent that the retention of the personal data is necessary:

(a) for exercising the right of freedom of expression in accordance with Article 80;

[1] http://ec.europa.eu/justice/data-protection/document/review2...

Re:US diplomat: If EU allows 'right to be forgotten' …it mig... by danso on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @09:28AM (#5170753)
Thanks for posting the direct link to the legislation. Two things I noted:

This right is particularly relevant, when the data subject has given their consent as a child, when not being fully aware of the risks involved by the processing, and later wants to remove such personal data especially on the Internet. However, the further retention of the data should be allowed where it is necessary for historical, statistical and scientific research purposes, for reasons of public interest in the area of public health, for exercising the right of freedom of expression, when required by law or where there is a reason to restrict the processing of the data instead of erasing them.

So these are the competing interests that I was alluding to. This: when not being fully aware of the risks involved by the processing, and later wants to remove such personal data especially on the Internet -- covers everyone who has ever posted something on the Internet and regretted it.

And this: for reasons of public interest in the area of public health, for exercising the right of freedom of expression -- is not at all a settled definition...freedom of expression lawsuits happen quite frequently. And speaking from the U.S. perspective, the EU's laws on free speech or quite different than the ones in the U.S.

Re:US diplomat: If EU allows 'right to be forgotten' …it mig... by mattmanser on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @08:24AM (#5170491)
EDIT: Sorry, kneejerk.

I think you've misunderstood.

This is a data protection act concerned with the right to delete information you have given an entity. It's for going to facebook and saying 'delete all the information I gave you, I no longer want you to have it and make sure you tell all the people you sold it to to delete it too'. It's nothing to do with freedom of the press, etc.

Re:US diplomat: If EU allows 'right to be forgotten' …it mig... by danso on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @08:32AM (#5170521)
Whoa no need for the ad hominem there, it's too early in the morning. I'll repost what the OP says...if the OP is wrong, then obviously my argument is wrong

From the OP: Under the draft Regulation individuals would enjoy a qualified 'right to be forgotten'. That right would enable them to force organisations to delete personal data stored about them "without delay". Organisations that have made the data public would be liable for the data published by third parties and would be required to "take all reasonable steps, including technical measures" to inform those groups to delete the information.

Your Facebook example is a good one, as it has defined data as including the content submitted by the user. You are correct that FB, the organization in this case, would be required to delete the data. But then the proposed law goes further, mandating that third parties need to delete the data. That is what my comment was referring to. Who do you think "third parties" mean? From usual interpretation, it means every and anyone besides the user and organization, hence, anyone who retweets or reposts or refers to the data made public by the organization

Re:US diplomat: If EU allows 'right to be forgotten' …it mig... by mattmanser on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @08:36AM (#5170538)
Sorry, edited.

It says in the quote personal data. Nothing to do with public information or information in the public interest.

Re:US diplomat: If EU allows 'right to be forgotten' …it mig... by danso on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @08:59AM (#5170636)
That's the rub, though, right?

Clearly, most users consider the content they've posted themselves as being personal data...when you delete your FB account, you expect that posted content to be deleted.

So if an ex-lover decides to screenshot some material that I only shared with my close friends and republishes it to Tumblr to embarrass me...does this law cover that? Sure, that seems like a clear cut case to most of us...and there are libel and harassment laws that cover this.

Now what if I make my affiliation with the KKK known on FB (such as Liking them and listing it under my job history). I renounce the organization and delete my FB account a month later later, but before then, someone has decided to post a screenshot of that ugly tidbit on their blog because while I was working as a cashier at Acme burger, they feel that I discriminated against them and so this KKK datapoint is proof.

Ten years later, does the public have a right to know that info, even if I spent the rest of the decade doing what I can to fight the KKK's efforts. Don't I have a right to be forgotten by search engines of my brief dalliance with the KKK?

Again, there are defamation laws that I can try to leverage (in the US, I would be considered a non public figure with stronger libel protections)...with this EU law, I now have e ability to bring a lawsuit against Facebook for not doing enough, in my opinion, to stop the dissemination of information after I deleted my account.

Now if your rebuttal is "well, it is a technical impossibility for FB to stop others from disseminating that information" Well, is it really? Or did FB just shirk their duties to save an extra buck? That's for the courts to decide...and as you well know, technical implementation is not always a deciding factor in the ruling.

I've used two extreme cases (most people hate the KKK so much that I assume they don't care if the person in the second scenario has their data shared)...but you can imagine all the other cases to fill the spectrum. You seem to take it for a given that the courts all agree what is in the public interest and what free speech is...but the reality is that such debates and lawsuits still go on today

Now I know no one sympathizes with the companies here...but given the litigious possibilities this law opens up, how do you think that might stifle initiatives that theoretically could fall afoul of this law? This is why I think it is akin to SOPA, which ostensibly protected the rights of content producers, but would've opened up new ways for certain companies to restrict and sue Google.