They're a horrific company and you'd be surprised how badly things can go wrong and how little recourse you have.
It turned out it was all a scam to get me to sign up for some sort of protection or monitoring service. And the sales rep was obviously an experienced scammer, not just some hapless phone operator. He eventually swore at me and hung up.
If those guys were on fire, I wouldn't piss on them to put it out. And as far as I'm concerned, anybody who works there is complicit in a (possibly technically legal) criminal enterprise.
a) I renewed the domain before expiry. Before that I had unlocked it for transfer but did not complete it since I realized that this might take a couple of days
b) Godaddy charged me for the domain renewal which effectively confirmed me as the owner for another year.
c) After 2 days, godaddy abruptly cancels the domain and transfers it to the registry even though my ownership is confirmed for the next one year.
It doesn't sound like any body else is here to blame except Godaddy.
From what I understand, they either
a) Did this because I initiated the transfer or b) I removed all credit cards from the system because I did not want renewals to happen without notice.
Here are the expiration policies I could find for GoDaddy, Namecheap, and Misk.com (us):
http://support.godaddy.com/help/article/608/what-is-your-pro...
http://www.namecheap.com/support/knowledgebase/article.aspx/...
The bulk of GoDaddy revenue comes from renewals and it's cheaper and easier to keep a customer as opposed to acquiring a new one.
It's much more likely that there's a bug in the code or some other non-malicious technical problem that's involved here.
As the GoDaddy representative correctly mentioned, it is the registries who are to blame for any restore fees. It's bad enough that you as a customer lost domains so Verisign, PIR, Afilias or any other gTLD registry shouldn't ask for anything else but the normal renewal fee.