News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Massive glacier collapse by ekianjo on Monday February 04, 2013 @10:29PM (#5168851)
Science is not fixed. A long time ago there was a long standing agreement that the sun and other planets were orbiting around the Earth, and they had complex models (Ptolemean ones) to calculate their trajectories, and that was reasonnably working well until humanity was able to get much more precise tools to measure the planets position and found inconsistencies.

The History of Science is full of such "largely admitted theories" that fell flat when new data, new methods were introduced.

What may seem "obvious" to a group of scientists now, even if they constitute 90% of the voices out there, may not be the actual truth.

I am not saying who is right or who is wrong, but even if you had a consensus, it would not mean that they get it right. We are ever learning.

Re:Massive glacier collapse by jpxxx on Monday February 04, 2013 @10:41PM (#5168883)
Your point doesn't have a point. If the question is "is there global warming, and are human beings substantially responsible?", the answer is "yes". You're saying "but it could always be no".

The answer is "yes", and some point past that is where the discussion currently exists.

Re:Massive glacier collapse by ekianjo on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @12:04AM (#5169247)
Maybe you did not get what I mean. I am saying there is no such thing as Scientific certitude just on the basis of people agreeing with each other. Scientific certitude is driven by an explanation of what is actually occuring, experimentation and reproduction of experiments. There is no way to "experiment" with Climate Change therefore all your models are just models and cannot be proved by experimentation. They are just theories, like Einstein's theory of relativity, which took a long time to be actually proven by experimental data.
Re:Massive glacier collapse by jpxxx on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @12:37AM (#5169347)
The downer of having only one Earth to work with is that you have only one Earth to work with.

Models, measurements, their comparisons to expected outcomes are all that we've got in this particular scientific department. The "experiment" is comparing your best model with what happened before and what happens next, not with running the same thing a thousand times.

Re:Massive glacier collapse by ekianjo on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @12:41AM (#5169356)
As I mentioned in another post, a "model" only works within its known limits. If the Earth is getting warmer outside of the limits of the established model, your model is not valid anymore. You know the xkcd joke about extrapolation, I guess?

I remember Al Gore showing the level of CO2 increase by jumping on an elevator and saying "imagine how much this increase will bring the temperature up!". But truth is, we don't know, nobody knows how much it will increase. There is no model data for that.