News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by pasbesoin on Monday February 04, 2013 @05:31PM (#5167642)
What pisses me off: It takes something like Google to compete with the entrenched oligopoly. And "we" are left waiting on their interest... or lack thereof.

When people finally try to self-organize (e.g. municipal development projects), the oligopoly turns to lawsuits and lobbying to beat them down.

The U.S. is such a hypocritical country. We laud competition, while in actuality we beat it down with ever fewer but larger and more deadly sticks.

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by rayiner on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:51PM (#5168555)
Read "Master Switch" by Tim Wu to see how we got from point A to point B.

There's no beef to your argument. The telco oligopolies are the result of two simple factors:

1) Telecom is a field with almost infinite economics of scale, which means that the natural tendency is towards consolidation until there is only one company left. It's the textbook case of natural monopoly.

2) Most of the existing telecoms arose through government-sanctioned monopolies. Those monopolies didn't arise because lobbyists padded the right pockets. Those monopolies arose because rural areas dominate U.S. politics (their votes count about 2x as much when election districts are accounted for). As a result, governments go to huge lengths to make sure that utility providers don't do the most economically sensible thing of concentrating infrastructure in densely-populated areas. One of the measures is giving utilities monopoly rights in return for their servicing rural areas.

The fact that it takes something like Google to take on these interests is completely unsurprising. They are one of the few companies with the dollars to address (1). They are also targeting, so far, only Kansas City (not a megalopolis, but an urban area of 1.5 million people) and thereby dodging (2).

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by joezydeco on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:59PM (#5168578)
Don't you think Kansas City had a municipal franchise agreement in place with telecom/cable providers before Google stepped in? Surely some modifications had to be made to allow a competing company to lay fiber.

In fact, that probably explains the whole "Hey kids! Get your town to enter the Google Fiber Lucky City Sweepstakes!" that was used to roll Google Fiber out. The winning city bought into the fiber idea so hard that the next step of kicking out the franchise agreements would be a snap.

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by rayiner on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:02PM (#5168589)
Google signed one of their own and it looks like the got a pretty sweetheart deal on it: http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Google-Can-Ditch-Kansas-C...

Lamenting about how political telecom can get is somewhat naive. Of course it's political. It involves digging up public/private property under municipal permission. It invokes the same contentious debates that all infrastructure projects invoke: richer neighborhoods versus poor one, urban ones versus rural ones, "not in my backyard," etc. As long as telecom involves digging up public land or using public spectrum, it will be intensely political.

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by joezydeco on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:15PM (#5168628)
Digging up yards is something local politicians could care less about. That's why easements exist. They're dug up all the time for electricity, gas, telephone, street lights, etc.

The political tradeoff comes from the franchise agreement. Your citizens want cable tv, and Comcast only wants to wire up the higher-end neighborhoods because they'll buy more services. Is that how you want to be portrayed? So you tell Comcast to make the deal: wire up the whole town, even that neighborhood 3000 feet up the hill, and we'll guarantee that nobody else can interfere with your physical plant investment. Comcast sleeps soundly at night, and so do the politicians.

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by JoeAltmaier on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:18PM (#5168637)
Franchise agreement == monopoly. Cable TV pays off their 'physical plant' investment in a couple of months, and spends the rest of their years raking it in.

Every small town in Iowa, the biggest house in town? The cable franchise operator.

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by rayiner on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:21PM (#5168648)
> They're dug up all the time for electricity, gas, telephone, street lights, etc.

All of those things are done under municipal authority. You can grant Comcast an easement to wire up your house, but what about digging under public streets or across your neighbor's yard?

Also, I don't disagree with the second part, but a fair characterization includes the fact that those people up on that hill have twice the votes per capita as the people living downtown.

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by joezydeco on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:38PM (#5168696)
You, as a property owner, don't grant easements to utilities. Those are owned by the municipality. You can't delete them.
Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by rayiner on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:44PM (#5168719)
Where do you think those easements come from? At some point, the municipality agreed to invoke it's eminent domain authority to let some utility lay cables, pipes, sewer lines, etc. That gave that utility a monopoly on service. In return for these monopolies, utilities extracted concessions like requiring the utilities to service everyone.
Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by buyx on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @05:37AM (#5170026)
One of the measures is giving utilities monopoly rights in return for their servicing rural areas.

This is an interesting observation. In South Africa, Telkom, the state monopoly had its monopoly status extended in return for rolling out services to rural areas. What really happened was that cellphones rapidly overtook landlines, and the common perception is that most of the landlines have been stolen and used for copper (although that isn't entirely true, I think, our maid has a cheap line in a rural area). Telkom's monopoly has expired, and it is crumbling, but South African telecoms were set back significantly.

South Africa's telecoms law was written with much input from SBC, an American corporation that bought a stake in Telkom ( http://twentythirdfloor.co.za/2007/08/27/telkom-sbc-and-a-fe... ).

Although most think that there was a purely ulterior motive in granting the monopoly, your comment makes me wonder if they were trying to replicate the de facto American model.

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by YokoZar on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @01:33PM (#5172322)
It should be noted that SBC was one of the child companies of AT&T before their anti-trust breakup -- SBC envisioned a new AT&T taking over South Africa, and succeeded beyond their expectations (AT&T was broken up before home internet and DSL even existed).

Somehow, AT&T was allowed to repurchase SBC, so now it's just AT&T again.

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by smutticus on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @05:27AM (#5170010)
> Those monopolies didn't arise because lobbyists padded the right pockets.

Absolute BS. Telecom lobbyists spend millions every year. I imagine they would stop if it were not necessary as you claim.

http://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/indusclient.php?id=B09

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by theorique on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @07:52AM (#5170367)
Competition is great for startups and small organizations, but not for Google, Microsoft, or the government.
Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by jholman on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @02:09AM (#5175272)
Google, and other healthy thriving large companies, love competition. When you already know you're the best in the world, you view competition the way Usain Bolt looks at Tyson Gay. "Come on, bring the noise. All you'll do is help me to beat my own world record, and I like that. So do your worst!"

Note I don't actually know that Usain Bolt feels that way, but many top athletes do (especially in "world record" type sports like racing). And of course this is my personal assessment of the situation, not the position of my employer, etc etc.

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by theorique on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @09:10PM (#5180089)
True, Google was not the best example since it is still young and entrepreneurial despite being large.

I'm thinking of companies that are hampered by (e.g.) heavy regulation, internal politics and competition, in mature and/or commodity industries.

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by javajosh on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:55PM (#5168104)
>When people finally try to self-organize (e.g. municipal development projects), the oligopoly turns to lawsuits and lobbying to beat them down.

Examples?

EDIT: Okay. Wow. Had no idea. Has any municipality tried to create a wireless mesh network that connected through a few high-bandwidth connections?

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by martythemaniak on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:00PM (#5168131)
How about the first result for "Municipal Fiber Lawsuit"? http://arstechnica.com/uncategorized/2008/09/telco-to-town-w...

There are plenty of other cases, but the OP is right. The telco incumbents will use any means necessary - propaganda ("it's anti-capitalist!"), bribes (aka, lobbying) and lawsuits - to keep extracting as much profit as possible from people while delivering the barest minimum service possible.

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by EricBurnett on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:02PM (#5168135)
Here's two, from a quick search:

Monticello, Minnesota (2008): http://www.ilsr.org/monticello-fiber-network-fighting-frivol...

Lafayette, Louisiana (2010): http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2010/05/lousiana-fiber-ne...

Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by dusing on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:17PM (#5168411)
I have friends down the road in MN and the speeds are amazing! They covered a pretty good chunk of homes at launch too.
Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by 31reasons on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:53PM (#5168561)
This is so absurd. So basically US is not a democracy. From networks to cabs, everywhere these companies need protection from disruption. But if Uber can do it in cab services, can't all Cities group together and fight ?
Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by rayiner on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:10PM (#5168615)
Yes, the U.S. isn't a democracy because NYC gave cab companies a service monopoly in return for agreeing to serve poor people in the Bronx.
Re:When Will the Rest of Us Get Google Fiber? by jseliger on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:33PM (#5168257)
This isn't directly related to what you're asking, but "The Great Verizon FiOS Ripoff" addresses another aspect of the basic problems in the broadband market: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bruce-kushnick/the-great-veriz... .