I would draw a distinction between productivity and innovation. The source of Walmart's productivity gains was not innovation within Walmart, but advances in technology, from which Walmart was able to take advantage of more quickly than competitors. Just because retail gained in productivity and Walmart is the biggest retailer does not imply that Walmart is the source of innovation. I do give Walmart credit for their aggressive play, but the business of retail is still that of a middleman with a storefront, inventory management, customer service and thin margins.
I applaud Amazon's efforts to prevent disruption with the Kindle and to move into the cloud. AWS is fairly innovative.
Re:Why Amazon Is Special and Apple Is Not
by jseliger on Sunday February 03, 2013 @11:44PM
(#5162474)
>I would draw a distinction between productivity and innovation
Again, check out the paper, the papers citing it, and the papers cited in its bibliography—based on that research, the distinction is fuzzy at best.
This isn't really true. Check out Emek Basker's famous paper "The Causes and Consequences of Wal-Mart's Growth" (econ.missouri.edu/working-papers/2006/wp0611_basker.pdf (and its citations)) and the work of other economists who estimate that WalMart, on its own may be responsible for an appreciable portion of U.S. productivity growth in the 90s and 2000s.
One major problem India suffers from right now is entrenched incumbents who prevent modern retail practices from reaching most of the country. A lot of people there would love for American-style retail practices to spread.