Re:Why Amazon Is Special and Apple Is Not
by mjmahone17 on Sunday February 03, 2013 @03:21PM
(#5160987)
Right, but the whole point of Costco is "currated" content: they get good deals on huge quantities, because they make sure not to carry every type of product. Variety isn't necessarily a good thing, and if Costco implemented free two-day shipping (for an additional fee), as well as an improved UI, they probably could become the biggest online "everyday" retailer (i.e. for things like cereal, toilet paper, etc.). Though I think it might be more likely that Fresh Direct, or a similar company, could get a stronger toehold on that market than Costco or Amazon.
Amazon's catalog is so much bigger than Costco's along two axes; more kinds of products, and more varieties of a given kind of product. The latter axis can be good for Amazon, since people have different utility functions, brand loyalties, etc. But one thing I like about Costco is that their catalog seems to be curated; whatever brand/model of a given thing they happen to carry, it's usually pretty decent. Amazon, by comparison, carries good and crap versions of pretty much everything, but you can use the customer reviews to separate the wheat from the chaff). By removing the paradox of choice, Costco not only reaps the usual benefit on the buyer's psychology, but is also able to negotiate better wholesale prices on the items they buy due to higher volume. Maybe that's a way for them to compete?