Of course, HN distorts this somewhat by just having one score for all the possible reasons a user might have to vote on a comment, and inevitably superstar posters get upvoted reflexively often drowning out better comments. But overall, as both a tool for measuring quality and a reward system it works pretty well.
By voting, we give each other points of a credibility currency that transcends individual discussions.
Just by talking to me, you've let me know what I said was worth at least a reply.
This is just opinion, so take it for what its worth... I'd much rather someone reply to me, email, chat whatever, and let me know what exactly they think rather than assign my words a value via a mouse click. Wouldn't you?
Yes, but I also upvoted you ;)
I essentially agree with you, it's just that I think karma has its place, too. And usually when I reply to a comment, I make it a point to give it a vote as well.
It would be interesting to see if hiding usernames for 24 hours has any effect on voting.
I've thought about this, actually, and based on my comment/karma history, it appears that I'm too dumb to keep from blurting out things people downvote.
I'm free of the tyranny of the hivemind by virtue of ignorance and stupidity!
I consciously say things I wouldn't otherwise because I know I have karma to burn. It's when you have < 100 karma you have to watch out otherwise you could end up in negative territory quickly and your posts be dead by default (the idea of voting people down for disagreement rather than stupidity is still going strong, it seems).
Side note: You may even be unconsciously censoring yourself in fear of losing karma. It's a similar effect to suddenly having a lot of followers on Twitter.