News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by tokenadult on Sunday February 03, 2013 @11:47AM (#5160126)
Surely this can't be legal under existing copyright law. From the article, "The District holds common law copyright, at a minimum, to all relevant intellectual property its city and school employees create, a spokeswoman said." I take it that the school district's lawyer was not consulted before that statement was made, or else the lawyer was a doofus about copyright law. There isn't any "common law copyright," in the first place. (FIRST EDIT: a reply to this comment correctly points out that the story is primarily about a "proposal by the Prince George’s County Board of Education" and that the District of Columbia public schools are a distinct public school system. So I should make clear that I think that ANY school district that thinks it can assert a copyright interest in pupil or student assignments is mistaken about the law, and parents should challenge districts that make such statements.)

The work-for-hire exception to the general copyright law principle that the right of copyright belongs to the creator from fixation is narrowly construed, and school pupils attending a public school don't meet the rather narrow exceptions that trigger the work-for-hire doctrine.

http://www.theiplawblog.com/archives/-copyright-law-ownershi...

http://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ09.pdf

School pupils are not employees of school districts. Works produced in the scope of employment by school district employees may indeed be works for hire (there is some scope for interpretation in applying this part of the work-for-hire doctrine) but, again, students and pupils are not employees of the school district. They have authorship rights in their works from the moment of fixation. (That students and pupils are usually minors, not adults, is an additional complication in asserting that right, but that doesn't pass the right to the school.)

Anecdote: I made a school art project in second grade, a picture of a Mongol horseman, that somehow was precociously good, probably because I had seen other such drawings at home when reading history books. The school's specialist art teacher was so impressed by the picture that she took it, and I HAVE NEVER SEEN IT AGAIN. Every time I tell this story, I encounter other adults who also remember producing an art project in school that was taken by a teacher, never to be returned. Thanks a lot.

My advice to parents, which I advise parents to memorize, whenever I speak at a public meeting about educational law: if a school official tells you that you must put up with some school rule, because the rule is the law, say, "What is your legal authority to ask me to do this?" Statutes and case holdings and administrative regulations have citations. If it's really the law, someone can look it up and see exactly what the law says. Schools can only make up policies under authority granted to the schools by other law-making bodies. And if a school district has a policy, it still needs to be written down somewhere. In my experience, most school district officials who say "It's the law" are nonlawyers and are often mistaken about what the law says. If a school tells you that you can't do what's right by your child because "it's the law," ask for the citation of the law. If it's really a law, there is a citation, and the law can be looked up. In the United States, under its Anglo-American system of law, the default assumption is individual liberty (and parents rather than schools acting in the interests of minor children), so make sure to check the specific law before believing your freedom is restricted by the law in the manner the school official claims.

SECOND EDIT: A different top-level comment in this thread mentions a policy of the University of California Berkeley. I have an inference about what that is about, and it would be enormously helpful to the discussion to link to the exact text of what students agree to as they enroll, which is surely a public document that very likely lives on the World Wide Web.

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by Petrushka on Sunday February 03, 2013 @12:09PM (#5160208)
PG County is Maryland, not DC. It's the county that wraps around the eastern side of the District, and includes the University of Maryland. The rules of the District don't apply to what they're trying to do. I think the author mentioned them (and those of Montgomery County, PG's far wealthier and higher performing neighbor) to show that the idea wouldn't be possible in those school districts.

Notably, PG County has an awfully run government that presides over a relatively low-income population generally composed of Latino immigrants and African-Americans pushed out of the District itself by rising home prices. I've seen a picture before of the average income levels in the counties surrounding DC. Montgomery, Arlington, Fairfax, and Loudoun counties are all top 10 in the nation. PG sticks out like a sore thumb. Adding to that, they have by far the most racist police force you'll find. A friend of mine has been pulled over and searched multiple times there solely because he is a young black driving a car that doesn't look like it got pulled off the scrap heap. The last thing that county needs is something that stifles the abilities of its younger residents to try and create something new and interesting for their local community and at-large.

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by Anechoic on Sunday February 03, 2013 @02:19PM (#5160717)
Notably, PG County has [..] a relatively low-income population

Really? According to wiki, the median household income is over $71,000 and 38% of households earned over $100,000. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prince_Georges_County,_Maryland...

edit: okay, I suppose PG county is lower income than Montgomery, Arlington, Fairfax, and Loudoun counties, but the population is certainly not "low income" even for a high-cost-of-living region.

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by doktrin on Monday February 04, 2013 @12:12AM (#5162584)
PG is a relatively large place, and county-wide statistics hide some very real poverty.

It also bears mention that, while not directly correlated, PG county has at times had a murder rate on par with Baltimore.

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by dpearson on Sunday February 03, 2013 @02:42PM (#5160813)
Compare that to other DC-area counties, though. Per the Washington Post [1], Fairfax, Loudoun, and Arlington all have median household incomes over $100,000. Montgomery sits at almost $93,000. So in comparison, $71,000 per year is low.

[1]: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/special/local/highest-i...

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by alistairSH on Sunday February 03, 2013 @02:57PM (#5160882)
Correct. PG County is only "low income" relative to its neighbors.

If memory serves, it's the wealthiest majority minority county in the nation.

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by SeanLuke on Monday February 04, 2013 @12:06AM (#5162560)
PG County has wide variance in income. Further out in the county there are fairly well-off people. But there is a dense population of urban poor near the DC border.
[deleted]
Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by ahoyhere on Sunday February 03, 2013 @03:26PM (#5161003)
I used to live in Greenbelt, in the heart of PG County, and my 2-bedroom-and-den semi-crappy apartment cost $1750 nearly 7 years ago. And Greenbelt is a DUMP. An expensive, expensive dump.

Since the apartments were all full — and not 6 people to a unit, either… -- there's only one conclusion… PG County is a lot wealthier than you think. It's not all in Bowie and "the north."

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by tedks on Sunday February 03, 2013 @09:05PM (#5162047)
Greenbelt probably has inflated housing prices, being so close to UMD College Park.
Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by DanBC on Sunday February 03, 2013 @12:05PM (#5160191)
> If a school tells you that you can't do what's right by your child because "it's the law," ask for the citation of the law. If it's really a law, there is a citation, and the law can be looked up. In the United States, under its Anglo-American system of law, the default assumption is individual liberty (and parents rather than schools acting in the interests of minor children), so make sure to check the specific law before believing your freedom is restricted by the law in the manner the school official claims.

Unfortunately they're likely to mumble some semi-related law and then call the police.

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by tokenadult on Sunday February 03, 2013 @12:13PM (#5160224)
Dan, to the contrary, the parents I have advised in this manner for two decades report good results in getting school districts to back away from illegal restrictions on family decisions once the parents show that they know how to ask about the law. Simply asking for a citation when a government official tells you what to do is enormously helpful. (It may be especially helpful here in Minnesota, where for more than twenty years we have had public school open enrollment and a reasonably easy-going homeschooling statute, thus giving parents the power to shop for a school that fits each child in the family.)

A local friend of mine has a piece of advice that shows her understanding of the world from being a programmer for a large insurance company rather than a lawyer. As she asked for school accommodations for her four children (now all grown up and in higher education or private employment), when told she couldn't get what her children needed, she would say, "Who do I talk to to get an exception?" She understood very well that schools are bureaucratic organizations, and that all bureaucratic organizations have some higher bureaucrat who can make exceptions to rules. (I think she learned that at the insurance company where she does her programming.) I now add her phrase to my parent talks to supplement the more lawyer-like phrase that I mentioned in my first comment in this thread.

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by DanBC on Sunday February 03, 2013 @01:16PM (#5160496)
> when told she couldn't get what her children needed, she would say, "Who do I talk to to get an exception?" She understood very well that schools are bureaucratic organizations, and that all bureaucratic organizations have some higher bureaucrat who can make exceptions to rules.

That's excellent advice, and it's something I quite often. "I don't know your system, and so I don't know who to ask or what questions to ask. What do you suggest?" turns unhelpful conversations into productive discussion.

In the UK there has been some problem with photographing your children at school events. Schools claim compliance with a variety of laws, but the reality is they just don't want people taking photographs.

(http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/2012/jun/23/photos-ch...)

(http://dpnow.com/7640.html)

> But only recently news emerged of a parent who, in 2007, was threatened with arrest by police as he arrived at his daughter's school if he proceeded to break the school's ban on photography at a nativity play. The same school in Leicestershire still has the ban in place, although photographs can be taken after the performance is completed.

This follows a weird restriction on photography in public in general in the UK. Youtube has many videos of people being told by police to stop taking photographs in public. This has been such a problem that one police service had to issue updated guidance.

(http://www.met.police.uk/about/photography.htm)

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by tedunangst on Sunday February 03, 2013 @02:47PM (#5160838)
What are they going to tell the police? "These parents won't let us copyright their children's work, please arrest them."?
Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by kevin_rubyhouse on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:09AM (#5163196)
More likely a notice would be issued and they would be taken to court if they refuse to comply.
Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by derleth on Sunday February 03, 2013 @04:45PM (#5161297)
Harassment. Making a scene, also known as disturbing the peace. Refusing to leave, which amounts to criminal trespass. Maybe even assault, if they're really feeling their oats and are willing to claim you made them fear for their safety.
Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by tedunangst on Sunday February 03, 2013 @04:56PM (#5161350)
If it gets to the point where a school official asks a parent to leave, my advice would be to walk away and call your favorite education lawyer. Do you really think refusing to leave is going to change their mind?
Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by derleth on Monday February 04, 2013 @12:51AM (#5162676)
> Do you really think refusing to leave is going to change their mind?

I think you missed my point: The fact they accused you of refusing to leave does not mean you did, in fact, refuse to leave.

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by josephlord on Sunday February 03, 2013 @07:17PM (#5161803)
> Anecdote: I made a school art project in second grade, a picture of a Mongol horseman, that somehow was precociously good, probably because I had seen other such drawings at home when reading history books. The school's specialist art teacher was so impressed by the picture that she took it, and I HAVE NEVER SEEN IT AGAIN. Every time I tell this story, I encounter other adults who also remember producing an art project in school that was taken by a teacher, never to be returned. Thanks a lot.

That isn't actually a copyright issue unless the teacher copies it and/or distributes it. It may still be some form of theft though that assumes it wasn't lost while in the teacher's care for valid reasons.

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by Retric on Sunday February 03, 2013 @12:44PM (#5160353)
Further schools are Already legally required to teach students so any contract signed to trade copywrite in exchange for attendance fails to give the parent or student anything thus failing to become a contract. (Contracts require both sides to gain something of value aka consideration.)

PS: Schools often run into this issue when trying to set up contracts with students / parents.

Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by Evbn on Sunday February 03, 2013 @04:39PM (#5161280)
Even with consideration, any contract signed by a student under threat of loss of education (which is a civil right), is signed under duress and therefore invalid.
Re:DC-area schools consider copyright policy that takes owne... by Natsu on Sunday February 03, 2013 @04:06PM (#5161150)
Incidentally, there is such a thing as common law copyright[1], but it's pretty obscure and I'm not really sure how it could apply here given that none of the works at issue were created before it got preempted in the 1970s. This policy is, quite simply, insane and I can't see what they intend to accomplish here.

While I can at least imagine them being able to get teachers to sign some sort of copyright transfer agreement, I have a really hard time seeing how they're going to be able to get the copyrights of students. Copyright law requires a written memorandum of transfer so what could they do? Tell them to sign a copyright transfer or be expelled?

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_law_copyright