Re:On Python security amidst recent Rails/YAML vulnerabilities
by jrochkind1 on Sunday February 03, 2013 @10:50AM
(#5159961)
> I don't think anyone will be confused because suddenly YAML.load doesn't execute arbitrary code.
An example of where people would be confused because YAML.load doesn't _instantiate arbitrary objects_ (which is what it really does, which results in ability to 'execute arbitrary code' as a poorly thought through side effect) -- is people using ActiveRecord::Base.serialize . Which would become broken if you were serializing any objects that weren't string, hash, integer, array.
While we've realized that allowing de-serialization of arbitrary objects ends up being incredibly likely to result in 'allowing execution of arbitrary code' -- referring to the problem simply as the latter confuses about the nature of the problem and the efficacy of various fixes.
An example of where people would be confused because YAML.load doesn't _instantiate arbitrary objects_ (which is what it really does, which results in ability to 'execute arbitrary code' as a poorly thought through side effect) -- is people using ActiveRecord::Base.serialize . Which would become broken if you were serializing any objects that weren't string, hash, integer, array.
While we've realized that allowing de-serialization of arbitrary objects ends up being incredibly likely to result in 'allowing execution of arbitrary code' -- referring to the problem simply as the latter confuses about the nature of the problem and the efficacy of various fixes.