Moreover, the sentencing guidelines are still full of harsh penalties. When Congress presents the authors of the guidelines with a maximum penalty of 25 years, it makes a five year prison term seem generous to the accused, notwithstanding that it is in actual fact an extremely harsh prison sentence in absolute terms.
And, correct me if I'm wrong, whether something is a felony is based on the maximum penalty rather than the imposed penalty. So even if your actual sentence is "only" a number of months under the sentencing guidelines and in practice, you're still a felon for the rest of your life with all of the disqualifications that come with it if the maximum penalty exceeded a year.
I don't think it's too much to ask for Congress to better differentiate between more and less serious crimes and to set appropriate maximum penalties for each.
I didn't say "ever" -- if sentences were too low then the maximums should go up, but we are clearly in no danger of that happening because as you point out, "Americans like throwing the book at criminals, or people they perceive to be criminals." There is a reason that we don't elect Supreme Court justices.
See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Federal_Sentencin...