Re:What The Rails Security Issue Means For Your Startup
by martinced on Friday February 01, 2013 @11:18AM
(#5151580)
"The "everybody has bugs" response is intellectually dishonest."
Indeed. It's the "fallacy of gray". Nothing is black or white, hence everything is gray. Nothing is 100% secure, nothing is 100% insecure, hence everything is "semi-secure": it's bad, but not too bad, because every language / API / server can be attacked.
You've effectively substituted a black/white dichotomy with something even worse: instead of having only two options (black or white), you now only have one: gray.
It is probably one of the most intellectually dishonest logical fallacy of all times and we keep seeing it more and more.
Indeed. It's the "fallacy of gray". Nothing is black or white, hence everything is gray. Nothing is 100% secure, nothing is 100% insecure, hence everything is "semi-secure": it's bad, but not too bad, because every language / API / server can be attacked.
You've effectively substituted a black/white dichotomy with something even worse: instead of having only two options (black or white), you now only have one: gray.
It is probably one of the most intellectually dishonest logical fallacy of all times and we keep seeing it more and more.
It's really concerning.