Whether there is signal here or not wasn't my point. There may well could be. My point was simply that the analysis provided by Nanex is spurious without a definition of the timestamps, where they came from, and their relationship to known reference points. Taking three events with a timestamp from each of: CQS, CME, and an arbitrary point in time such as 10:30:00 and then asserting that events observed within a CQS or CME event stream happened "before" the arbitrary point in time, 10:30:00, is impossible.
Unless either (a) one observes CQS, CME, and the event scheduled for 10:30:00 from a known reference and accounts for all variables (differing transit latencies, etc) or (b) each of the generating events are known synchronized and the current state of that synchronization is observable (CQS lags CME by 475us, government event source leads CME by 1.2ms, etc). Clearing (b) is not happening today. (a) can be accomplished by Nanex, if they so choose.
Doing so doesn't give them a sensationalist headline that finds its way to the top of HN.
We had six independent connections to the exchange (hitting different servers) and we'd reverse engineered the exchanges internal infrastructure so based upon the timing of their messages, the tcp packet headers and their own timestamps we knew exactly what clocks their internal servers were running on (more valuably in our case is it also gave us their internal latency figures). Half the time we knew when their clocks were drifting before they did and could tell them which internal server had the wrong time.
This stuff is hard, you need to know a lot about network latency and time to make sure you're doing it right (have a look at the NTP spec for starters), there's probably only a handful of people in the world who are capable of nailing it and probably most of them work in the military or atomic physics research labs.
Funnily enough, Google appeared to have made it work well enough for a distributed database: http://research.google.com/archive/spanner.html
Instead, we see a signal within each dataset and symmetry between them. It could still be a data aberration, but that would implicate the CME and NYSE of having irregular clocks, a far more serious problem than some twat front-running a government report.
Most likely is that this is a real trading signal, but not one based on insider information.