Consequently, it's not necessarily at the determination of a lawyer, but I think the ICO has acknowledged that this is a difficult proposition so is taking a softer approach to enforcement.
At the very least the distinction could very easily be drawn between cookies which facilitate the sharing of information on the user's usage of multiple sites, to cookies which deal solely with the user's usage of the site where the cookie is set.
[1] http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2...
Isn't consent assumed by the fact that they've configured their browser to accept cookies?
The E-Privacy Directive specifically contemplates browser solutions as being a potential solution, however, I understand that at this stage, there isn't an acceptable implementation.
If for example a browser on first load asked what I wanted to do with cookies during that session, that might be acceptable.
I suspect browser makes are hesitant to work towards a solution because it would obviously be a blanket policy when it may be more appropriate for a more nuanced one dependent on each each site's cookie usage.
You can obviously configure cookies in your browser settings but I imagine for most users this option is overly complex for them to understand.
Can't one argue the same thing for setting up your website to be compliant with this law?
The fact that the easy and free solution is to just tell users to turn off all cookies in their browsers makes any laws of this type a waste.
And the arbitrator of this decision is: Some lawyer? This is why this entire law is so fantastically absurd.