Re:UK High Court Finds Programming Languages Uncopyrightable
by ig1 on Thursday January 31, 2013 @09:33AM
(#5145132)
Patents protect implementation of ideas; not ideas per-se.
Re:UK High Court Finds Programming Languages Uncopyrightable
by Cushman on Thursday January 31, 2013 @11:29AM
(#5145729)
That's not totally true; in the case of software, an implementation is code, which is copyrightable. The idea, the functioning of the code, is not copyrightable, but it may be patentable, because a patent is a more restricted protection on a more abstract idea.
Re:UK High Court Finds Programming Languages Uncopyrightable
by chii on Thursday January 31, 2013 @09:15PM
(#5148794)
patents protect inventions, not ideas. For physical object, this is easily discerned, but sometimes, it gets muddy when talking about a protocol, or some sort of algorithm. I dislike software patents, but the intention of patents isn't to protect an abstract idea (whether its been twisted to do so is another argument for another day...)
Re:UK High Court Finds Programming Languages Uncopyrightable
by Cushman on Thursday January 31, 2013 @11:25PM
(#5149202)
But an invention is obviously a kind of idea. Patents and copyright both protect kinds of ideas; that's why we call them intellectual property.
Re:UK High Court Finds Programming Languages Uncopyrightable
by aidenn0 on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:39AM
(#5149716)
You actually patent running the algorithm on a general purpose machine, not the code itself. Code is unpatentable.
How are patents justified if the law recognizes that monopolizing ideas is bad?