News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK High Court Finds Programming Languages Uncopyrightable by Osmium on Thursday January 31, 2013 @08:56AM (#5144945)
From the language you quoted above it sounds to my un-trained ear like he's comparing a programming language to a natural language.

I wonder how many of our problems are due to deciding to call them "programming languages" rather than something like "programming notation" instead? There seems to be a conceptual problem, especially among people who don't program, as to just what a programming language actually is.

Re:UK High Court Finds Programming Languages Uncopyrightable by tehwalrus on Thursday January 31, 2013 @09:14AM (#5145040)
Indeed, I think this is the principal problem in the way the judge gives his conclusion.

However, Programming statements are definitely "language" as linguists discuss, in that they have notions of syntax, and so on - i.e. there are Good Reasons they are called languages.

Re:UK High Court Finds Programming Languages Uncopyrightable by webreac on Thursday January 31, 2013 @09:11AM (#5145026)
The programming language is the language used to give instructions to a machine. For me, it is very similar to a natural language. What do you mean by "programming notation" ?
Re:UK High Court Finds Programming Languages Uncopyrightable by Osmium on Thursday January 31, 2013 @09:19AM (#5145065)
For me, a programming language is closer to mathematical notation than it is to a natural language that people use to communicate with each other. It's rigorous, logical, and typically the product of one entity rather than a natural language which is the product of everyone who uses it.

To put it another way, since the quote mentioned this, I don't think it's fair to compare a dictionary for a natural language to a dictionary for a computer language, because they're quite different things. One records and documents a process already happening [language evolution], while another is the process itself [language creation].

Just a personal opinion, that's all -- I just think analogies can be stretched too far, and by calling computer languages "languages" I think it's backed the discourse about them into a corner a little bit. Which is not to say all comparisons between computer language and "normal" languages are wrong, just that they're not really appropriate in this instance when discussing copypwritability.

Re:UK High Court Finds Programming Languages Uncopyrightable by Colliwinks on Thursday January 31, 2013 @09:36AM (#5145145)
What is meant by a 'language' is actually fairly well defined mathematically: That is something that can be described by a number of grammars. These in turn can be categorised (see the Chomsky Hierarchy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chomsky_hierarchy)

In that sense, programming languages, regular expressions, and natural language can all be identified by what types of grammar can define them.