Re:Too Few Astronauts Have Died
by smsm42 on Thursday January 31, 2013 @01:14AM
(#5143766)
>>>> Smarts don't replace atoms. Nor do they replace joules.
Again, platitudes and proof are very different things. So far I've seen "sensible studies", and I can't see how they are different from the equally "sensible studies" in 70s that predicted worldwide resource exhaustion and mass hunger by 2000s.
>>>> After the Great Depression we had vast stores of oil and most of these resources were barely touched
We still have vast stores of oil and other hydrocarbons, many of which aren't even touched for ecological/political reasons. And there are also biotechnologies that allow conversion of solar energy, which are not very economically viable now, but if we start running out of stored hydrocarbons - can serve as one of the replacements. Of course, Sun will go out too sometime, but let's not worry about it just yet.
>>>> So it's highly likely there's a causal relationship there that will have negative consequences as we slide down the other side of the energy resource curve.
That's like saying since winning the lottery positively correlates with income increase, the only way to have sustainable income is to play a lot of lottery, and if one gets rid of lotteries, economic collapse is sure to follow. Of course having tons of oil is useful to whatever little petro-monarchies that have it. But it does not make Venezuela world's most advanced country and it does not make countries which do not have it less advanced.
Again, platitudes and proof are very different things. So far I've seen "sensible studies", and I can't see how they are different from the equally "sensible studies" in 70s that predicted worldwide resource exhaustion and mass hunger by 2000s.
>>>> After the Great Depression we had vast stores of oil and most of these resources were barely touched
We still have vast stores of oil and other hydrocarbons, many of which aren't even touched for ecological/political reasons. And there are also biotechnologies that allow conversion of solar energy, which are not very economically viable now, but if we start running out of stored hydrocarbons - can serve as one of the replacements. Of course, Sun will go out too sometime, but let's not worry about it just yet.
>>>> So it's highly likely there's a causal relationship there that will have negative consequences as we slide down the other side of the energy resource curve.
That's like saying since winning the lottery positively correlates with income increase, the only way to have sustainable income is to play a lot of lottery, and if one gets rid of lotteries, economic collapse is sure to follow. Of course having tons of oil is useful to whatever little petro-monarchies that have it. But it does not make Venezuela world's most advanced country and it does not make countries which do not have it less advanced.