I'm saying there are no situations in which I'd want more than a single physical phone. I've used more than a single physical phone, like when I'm outside the US and want a local cellphone number but don't want to lose my US number, but in every situation I'd prefer to keep a single physical phone.
You've never lived or worked in a building with terrible cell phone reception
Switch providers. Though, ideally, I should be able to get calls through VoIP on my WiFi.
had a dead battery but still really needed people to be able to get a hold of you
It's easier to find/carry a charger than it is to notify everyone that needs to be able to get a hold of me of the new number.
had your phone stolen, or had your simcard go bad?
These are exceptional situations. I can get a phone replaced within a day in such a scenario. If it's urgent I can borrow a friend's cellphone.
But the multiple phone number management thing, that's really just a marketing hook, the easiest possible sell for the mass market right now, isn't it? This service provides all of the features you could want when managing voice communications, completely independent from a physical device. I mean, really, why even have a phone at all? Just plug into your voice service however you damn well please, that's the actual story here.