If they do not guarantee any return on whatever investment they sell then they are under no obligation to look for their clients best interests.
It happened during the subprime mortgage crisis where banks would sell derivatives to their clients and short the same clients because they knew the products were bad. And it is totally legal.
So who is to blame ? the banks ? or the elected representatives that made these things legal ? in the end the people is , for electing people that serves bank interests.
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/16/business/16goldman.html?_r...
However, it is worth noting that after Goldman agreed to pay the fine their stock price rose. This indicates that the stock market believed they got off lightly, so while officially illegal it does appear to be a reasonable business model.
This is indeed true.
>in fact , that's how they make most of their money
This however requires some proof. They do make money this way but to say that this is how banks make "most" of their money is way off by my understanding and I work in the industry.
In many ways it's no so different with the managing agents my building co-op appoints. We know they're screwing us every year, but at least we know how they're doing it, while with a new agent we'd have no idea!
In the prospectus filed with the SEC[1], Goldman disclosed that "...with regard to your notes, from time to time, we and/or our affiliates: (1) expect to acquire, or dispose of positions in listed or over-the-counter options, futures or other instruments linked to the index stock, (2) may take or dispose of positions in the securities of the index stock issuer itself, (3) may take or dispose of positions in listed or over-the-counter options or other instruments based on indices designed to track the performance of the New York Stock Exchange or other components of the U.S. equity market, and/or (4) may take short positions in the index stock or other securities of the kind described above — i.e., we and/or our affiliates may sell securities of the kind that we do not own or that we borrow for delivery to purchaser."
Let me paraphrase Warren Buffett: if you're playing poker with the big boys and you don't know who the patsy is, you're the patsy.[2]
--
[1] http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/886982/00011046591300...
[2] Buffett's original quote: http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/29147-if-you-ve-been-playing...