News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by justin_vanw on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:15PM (#5129734)
This has the usual journalist bias of putting all graduates in the same bucket. I would like to see the same statistic, but with Mathematics, Physics, Chemistry, EE, Mechanical Eng., etc all in their own buckets.

There seems to be some kind of outrage that you can go to a good school and get a 4 year degree and end up working with people who just graduated high-school. New grads were probably led up the garden path and not given realistic expectations. On the other hand everybody knows there are no jobs for English, Communications, Journalism, or any of the various 'Unemployment Studies' programs. Everyone knows this, it's past common knowledge and well on it's way to becoming a cliche.

Basically, I guess you can boil down what I'm saying as, "If you partied in college, and didn't take classes that were hard: you didn't learn anything, and that is why nobody will pay you for access to your training."

It used to be that certain kinds of jobs were reserved for a 'college man', but that was because that was synonymous with white and upper middle to upper class. The great liar, statistics, said that a college degree was highly correlated with lots of great outcomes, higher income, better employment, etc. The government started laying lots of money into getting everyone to go to college, without realizing that people weren't paying for the college part of college grads, they were paying for the stuff that college was correlated with. Like if the British started sending more people to Eton because they wanted to increase the size of the royal family.

These days who you know matters as much as ever. However, and this is kind of new, since the 20th century (or post Edison anyway), you can have a very comfortable and low risk life regardless of where you started, if you can learn enough technical stuff. Rich people and companies will pay to rent your brain all day. They will only pay, though, if your brain can do things that most brains can't, it's like anything else, value comes from scarcity.

So, if you are going to Harvard and your dad went to Harvard and your parents friends are as rich as they are, study whatever, you'll be fine. If your parents had to show up to work and had a boss, or worse if you are on scholarship, for the love of god study something with some cash value.

“I must study politics and war, that my sons may have the liberty to study mathematics and philosophy, natural history and naval architecture, in order to give their children a right to study painting, poetry, music, architecture, tapestry, and porcelain.” - John Adams

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by xijuan on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:42PM (#5129905)
I don't like what you said. You made it sound like that English and Journalism are easy majors. Even though it is harder to find jobs with those majors right now, they are not necessarily easy majors. In fact, depending on your talents,these majors can be very hard. Taking me as an example, I can never imagine myself majoring in English or Journalism because I dislike writing and I have never done too well in my English courses. To me these two majors would be harder than Math and Chemistry. On the other hand, my friend who is a history major is naturally good at writing but has very difficult times understanding Math related materials. I always admire her for her writing skills and always ask her for help when it comes to writing application and essays. She always wishes that she could be good at Math. Also what majors make good money also depends on the time we are living in. I don't know about American history but I know in Chinese history during the 1910s,people with arts majors would make more money. At that times, China was going through an intellectual revolution in which Western ideas were being introduced. At that times, many scholars would abandon their engineering, economic and medicine degrees and become writers or journalists.

Edit: I don't live in China....

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by politician on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:07PM (#5130056)
The idea that we should be rewarded for doing something hard, regardless of its value, is a consequence of a nation weaned on video games. Navigating a maze may be hard, and you might have a natural talent about it, but the real question is whether that's a skill other people consider worth paying enough for to cover your overhead. The market is voting against History, Journalism, etc. Learn a skill (or build a product) valuable to other people and you'll do fine.

Downvoters: I like video games, I just don't expect to payed for my RTS skills.

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by justin_vanw on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:57PM (#5129993)
I have no idea what the difficulty of various majors are in China.

Now, let me put this caveat in the front: At a good University, there are people who are serious and will amaze you in the following majors. Those people will be successful, and go on to graduate school and eventually become academics. But that doesn't change the fact that...

In America, the following majors are a joke. If you are bright and can read wikipedia, you will find that two hours of reading will leave you ahead of 90% of the people majoring in these things in knowledge of their major: Criminal Justice History Journalism English Kinesiology Communications Anthropology Religious Studies, Comparative Religions

And of course there are things that are more about passion and talent: Anything Art (Film, painting, photography, music)

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by krakensden on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:13PM (#5130083)
English and Journalism are considered easy majors for Americans at American universities. They typically require less time to prep for class, and have assignments that don't require as much time to complete.

Entry level jobs typically don't pay very well, and you're competing with everyone in the world who can write English, unlike, say, lawyers, who are competing with people who live and are licensed in their particular subsection of America.

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by idiot900 on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:54PM (#5129964)
No. He was commenting primarily on the low market value of English/Communications/etc, and less on whether they are easy things to do. They may be quite hard, but it's easier for an engineer to get paid to be an engineer than it is for humanities majors to do likewise and be paid the same amount. Yes it depends on what time we are living in, but currently we are living in the present.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by greghinch on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:40PM (#5130210)
I don't think OP said they are easy majors. Rather that graduating with a degree in those fields doesn't leave you very employable.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by ChuckMcM on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:28PM (#5130156)
You did sort of step into it there with the wide brush. But there is an interesting point that you allude too but don't state. STEM [1] degrees require a facility with executing procedural tasks, creating and testing against a hypothesis, and evaluating the result. Those skills are widely applicable. Not having those skills will limit your options (independently of going to College or not).

I made a suggestion to my Alma Mater that they consider making these "general ed" classes for all majors, basically making every major require 1 semester of calculus, 2 semesters of science, one semester of engineering, and one semester of computer science/technology. The theory being that these have become basic skills in our society as much as English composition, history, and the arts are.

[1] STEM - Science, Technology, Engineering, Math

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by cadlin on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:07PM (#5130053)
This comment (and article) are silly without comparing college graduates with "unemployable" degrees to people who only have a high school diploma.

If you look at minimum wage data (which would presumably filter out "high earning degrees"), you find that 7.3% of minimum wage employees have bachelor degrees or higher. This is certainly not zero, but it's evidence that unemployable degrees have some value. Unfortunately, there's not very good data on compensation by major.

65% of minimum wage employees have high school diplomas but not a bachelor's degree, and 27.7% don't have a high school diploma (this presumably includes high school students). Interestingly, there are about 1000 people in the country with a doctoral degree who work at a minimum wage job.

Source (page 8): http://www.bls.gov/cps/minwage2011.pdf

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by randomdata on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:35PM (#5130189)
"it's evidence that unemployable degrees have some value."

I see a different picture. Of those old enough to have obtained a degree, approximately 14% earn a minimum wage income, which is only a few points off the adult population at large. That indicates to me that minimum wage earners are fairly evenly distributed through the population, regardless of educational attainment.

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by cadlin on Monday January 28, 2013 @05:03PM (#5130963)
You're reading the data wrong. 7.3% of minimum wage workers have a bachelor's degree or higher.

I assume you were looking at the number 13.5%, which is the percentage of minimum wage hours worked by those with bachelor degrees alone.

Another way of looking at this: 30.9% of Americans over the age of 25 have a bachelor's degree. There are 122 million Americans 25 or older. That means about 38 million of them have a bachelor's degree or higher. There are 279,000 Americans with bachelor degrees or higher that make minimum wage. That means a maximum of .73% of Americans with bachelor degrees make minimum wage. Adding younger people with degrees dilutes the number further.

56.7% of Americans over 25 are somewhere between a high school degree and a bachelor's. If we do the same math above, we get that there are 69 million Americans with a high school diploma but not a bachelor's. And 2.5 million of them make minimum wage. That's 3.6%, which is a difference of about a factor of 5.

Dealing with people between 18-25 probably skews the data towards a lower percentage of minimum wage workers more in favor of those without a bachelor's, but I think the point still stands. Unfortunately the BLS doesn't subdivide the data by both age and educational attainment.

Population by age: http://www.census.gov/population/age/ Educational attainment: http://www.census.gov/hhes/socdemo/education/

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by randomdata on Monday January 28, 2013 @05:21PM (#5131077)
"You're reading the data wrong."

I think you may have read my post wrong. According to the link, 1,933,000 people old enough to have a degree work a minimum wage job. Of them, 279,000 have a degree. That is 14.4%.

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by cadlin on Monday January 28, 2013 @07:40PM (#5131676)
There are 1,933,000 people over the age of 25 who work at a minimum wage job. There are 279,000 people of all ages who have a bachelor's degree or higher. Any data linking the two has to be speculative (like the numbers I provided in my previous post).
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by michaelochurch on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:58PM (#5129999)
I feel like this attitude that English is an easy major smacks of the guy who goes to a meditation retreat for his competitiveness, never gets the point of what he's there for, sits there bored and learns nothing, then walks away saying, "That was easy, and I was the best meditator there."

It's easier to bullshit, but that's largely because of lenient grading. You can actually fail a math course if you don't understand any of it. If you fail an English course, you typically get a C.

Also, while I think STEM majors are more valuable, I would argue that it's a sign of cultural decline that English and history majors often can't get quality jobs. Sure, if you're not from money, you should study something practical. That is true. But it sucks that so many people can't study humanities and have decent careers.

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by SatvikBeri on Monday January 28, 2013 @04:09PM (#5130648)
I have noticed a large number of people who have a mental block that they "can't do Math" or "can't learn foreign languages." In contrast, I have not noticed people with a mental block towards History/English/etc. I think the notion of STEM majors as "hard" is bad marketing on our part.

From my experience, these mental blocks can be overcome. One trick that worked for me was to tell my students that I would take full responsibility for their learning during a tutoring session. That helped them relax and learn much more effectively. Alas, I was never able to get past the deeper beliefs-I suspect a therapist would have better luck with that.

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by justin_vanw on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:01PM (#5130011)
I'm not sure if this disagrees or agrees with your point, but English is an easy major because stupid people can complete it without a lot of stress, and come out with a degree even though they still have absolutely no special ability in, nor deep understanding of English.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by JoeAltmaier on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:03PM (#5130023)
Don't go showing your biases or anything, but I remember quite a few not-very-bright Engineers getting their degree too.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by michaelochurch on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:06PM (#5130044)
Is this limited to English? I've interviewed some appallingly bad programmers with PhDs from top-5 CS departments. I'm sure they had high IQs, but they were awful programmers and, thus, in the context I cared about, were stupid.