News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by betterunix on Monday January 28, 2013 @12:52PM (#5129593)
"Overeducated" implies that there is some upper-bound on the appropriate education a person should receive if they have a particular career. It is the sort of elitist, aristocracy-favoring view of the world that we should be trying to discourage.

Of course, when going to college means taking on mountains of inescapable debt, not getting a high-paying job afterwards is problematic. That's why we need to change the way we pay for college education, so that we can have a society of well-educated independent thinkers, rather than one where people start out in life just a millimeter away from indentured servitude.

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by asdfologist on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:14PM (#5129732)
You're taking that word way out of context. "Overeducated" here means getting an academic credential where it isn't necessary. There's nothing wrong with learning a lot, but that doesn't mean you need to pay $200K for a college degree.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by muzz on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:17PM (#5129749)
Average student debt is $25K, hasn't been increasing that much, except in for-profit schools like Univ of Phoenix:

http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/01/student-...

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by DannyBee on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:54PM (#5129967)
Student debt for bachelors, maybe.

Even then this doesn't tell you the cost of education (IE how much you + your parents are spending), only how much money you still owed at the end.

If it takes eating your parents 401k to pay for college, that's still very harmful, even if you only have 36k debt at the end.

Lastly, all the numbers are normalized to 2009 dollars, which makes them hugely misleading. If you look at the original data source, in original dollars, the debt load has gone up by ~50% in <10 years

(They are also estimates, with 2009 being based on 17,000 out of 1.6 million degree earners. i'm too lazy to look up the methodology in the referred report to see if it's sane)

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by randomdata on Monday January 28, 2013 @03:26PM (#5130438)
A student in a four year program will lose about $150,000 at time of graduation by simply not working during that time, never mind any costs that are incurred by the schooling itself.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by nazgulnarsil on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:54PM (#5129965)
correcting rampant old wives tales is pretty much a thankless job, so thank you.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by randomdata on Monday January 28, 2013 @03:41PM (#5130517)
'"Overeducated" here means getting an academic credential where it isn't necessary.'

I would say it was said to set a worthiness factor on a profession; to imply that taxi drivers are not valuable to our society.

The software industry most certainly does not require a degree either, and we have countless success stories of people in the industry without degrees or relevant degrees, but we wouldn't say someone with a degree is overeducated to do the job because we regard programmers in high standing. Imagine if this article was about all the overeducated CS grads working as programmers. We'd be all up in arms about it, even though there is no theoretical difference. You still need complex skills and education to be a good taxi driver. It is not something just anyone can hop into the car and do.

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by asdfologist on Monday January 28, 2013 @03:53PM (#5130572)
Not true. Many, if not most, programming jobs require a college degree to even apply, at least in the US.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by randomdata on Monday January 28, 2013 @04:07PM (#5130636)
If what you say is true, I expect primary industry plays a significant role. Vocal software companies certainly do not enforce such requirements. Not even the big ones like Google and Facebook.

If you are writing software for a company that makes, say, shoes, maybe things are different. You might even need to have a degree to get a job as a driver in the shoe company, as a result of their overall business culture.

I'd love to look over the numbers if you still have them handy.

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by betterunix on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:07PM (#5130049)
That sounds like an argument for reforming how college is paid for. Like, say, having colleges that people can go to at no cost, without burdensome debts. There are countries on this planet that have managed to do such things...
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by asdfologist on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:50PM (#5130261)
... like socialist countries? In this case it's definitely not "no cost"; people pay for these with high tax rates.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by betterunix on Monday January 28, 2013 @04:25PM (#5130756)
That as "at not cost to the student." Yes, society as a whole has to pay for education, but the long-term benefits more than offset that cost. Better-educated people are less likely to fall for scams, they are more likely to make good decisions about their health, etc. Democratic systems require educated populations: poorly educated voters will make really bad decisions about who or what to vote for, or will base their votes on things that are utterly irrelevant to society's problems.

This is not terribly different from the government paying for scientific research (disclosure: I am a grad student who is paid out of a grant from DARPA). Government-funded is a key component in scientific progress; while industry-funded research can make strides, there are certain lines of work that do not have a clear enough market potential for any business to justify funding, but which have expanded human knowledge and in some cases opened new markets (and thus paved the way for further research by the private sector). The public as a whole benefits from government-funded research in the long-term, even if it means higher taxes.

So while I will admit that you are correct in a technical sense -- education does cost someone, somewhere -- the bigger issue here is not whether education will be paid for, but who will benefit from it once it is paid for. Our current system of student loans has the effect of ensuring that people from a certain minimum economic background are more likely to benefit from education than others, and the wealthier a person's family is the more able they are to benefit from a good education. The effects are not hard to see: poor people are more likely to make bad decisions about their health, more likely to fall victim to scams (including but not limited to the lottery), more likely to commit crimes, and are less able to improve their lives or organize themselves for change. It would help to improve high school education, but that can only go so far.

The real issue here is the attitude Americans (and to be fair, plenty of other country's citizens) have about education. People tend to assume that college is high-end vocational training, where people go in order to get a "good job," which is typically defined as a job that pays a lot of money. The result of the popularity of that view is what we see today: a system of student debt, which has undermined the quality of college education and somewhat ironically undermined the confidence employers have in job candidates who present a college degree. With students who only care about the amount of money they will make after they graduate, who often try to rush through school so they can accumulate less debt and can begin paying it back faster, colleges have relaxed their requirements, slashed the budgets of departments that lack a clear vocational mission, and pressured professors to not make courses too rigorous. You see this sort of thing in computer science, where many departments only offer one or two theoretical courses per year, and where students can graduate having little to no understanding of fundamental CS questions (like the P vs. NP question) or who cannot state the answer to the Entscheidungsproblem or explain its significance.

Were we to adopt a different view -- the view that a well-educated populace is necessary for a healthy democracy and that society needs a critical mass of people who are capable of thinking for themselves as a protection against the formation of an aristocracy -- we would never have wound up in this situation. There would be no question that education should be paid for as a public good, certainly not in a country whose constitution forbids titles of nobility and guarantees that all citizens have certain rights regardless of their place in society. In theory, that is why we have a public education system at all; in practice, our public education system has been systematically undermined, and the voting public has long forgotten why we have public schools at all. At the rate we are going, there will be no public education at all when my hypothetical grandchildren are born, there will only be vocational academies and private schools, and poor people will only receive the minimum training needed to work in service and maintenance jobs.

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by jeffdavis on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:03PM (#5129661)
I would add to that: being a cab driver out of college doesn't mean you are making a career out of it. It's called an "entry-level" job for a reason.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by larrys on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:18PM (#5129751)
Could also be an immigrant with a degree from another country that is learning the language or getting situated as well.

That said the story doesn't point to the trend from 1970 till now. The data is available I'm assuming. But did this happen evenly over time or in the last 5 or 10 years or?

Re:Overeducated and underemployed by muzz on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:09PM (#5129697)
Or a stop-gap job being taken on during a period of massive job destruction (something like 7M jobs were lost from 2007-2010)
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by adrr on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:57PM (#5129990)
Entry level job is a job teaches your skills and gives you the experience to get a better job in the same field. Taxi cab driver isn't an entry level job, being an intern or assistant is an entry level job.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by danilocampos on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:09PM (#5130059)
Taking a data entry gig at a large firm is entry-level. You can grow into bigger things there. Driving taxis is a dead-end job. There's nowhere to go once you achieve mastery.
Re:Overeducated and underemployed by Turing_Machine on Monday January 28, 2013 @02:44PM (#5130233)
If you really paid attention and grokked the problems with the taxi business on a fundamental level, you might be in a position to launch a competitor for Uber.

But yeah, unlikely.