Re:The IDE as a value
by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday January 30, 2013 @08:21AM
(#5139316)
This is quite the standard dynamic languages argument, I'm not seeing much new here but this wasn't meant to be new. However, my point is that this is heavily object-oriented and heavily imperative. It is just a different kind of object system that people might not be used to. If this ever catches on, we'll just need another Treaty of Orlando to re-harmonize the object community.
To be honest, a lot of the object system seems to be confused and muddled. I mean, there are a million different ways to get the kind of flexibility in what the author call "behaviors" (a term incredibly overloaded, BTW), protocols, traits, type classes, etc...dynamic mixins are nothing new here also (I've designed a couple of research languages with dynamic mixin inheritance, fun stuff).
As an academic, I want to see reasons why X was chosen and comparisions with previous systems that chose Y instead; but I know I won't get this from most of the people who do the interesting work in this field, so I have to figure it out for myself. Calling this an object system opens up a floodgate of related systems that I can compare it against.
The idea of 'behaviors' also provides flexibility in what functions can act on any grouping of data - the key value pairs needn't be associated with a 'class' which dictates what the associated functions will be adds more flexibility. As the author hints, there are other ways of achieving this agility - dynamic mixins.
Finally, while having a well defined protocol (or API or endpoint or whatever you want to call it) is valuable and helps organize code, I think taking this idea to the extreme and saying that every single object or piece of data you pass around as arguments or return values from these end points needs to be expressed as an abstract protocol itself is where you really start to lose. An expected format of the data structures of the arguments and return values can and should be part of an API, but needing to wrap them in objects doesn't really help - and that's where this trend I speak of begins to seem like progress to me.