Even worse, they allow government to show how engaged and open they are by listening to the voice of the people. All for the cost of having some intern draft sugar coated "everything is gonna be alright" responses.
Media coverage of petitions such as the death start or the Piers Morgan controversy even enforce the perception, that petitions are not more than a bad joke to give "some weirdos" a place to voice their "problems".
1. Put pressure on a specific person or group of people to make a specific change.
2. Bring attention of an issue to a larger audience (i.e.: the press, a congressmen's constituents, etc)
Having those things goes a long way to making these online petitions useful, but without them you'd just end blowing around a lot of hot air.