I think you're spot on. This is fluff posing as profoundness with irrelevant nuggets of topicality mixed in for flavor.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie
by InclinedPlane on Monday January 28, 2013 @01:46AM
(#5127489)
It also struck me as written by someone on the East Coast, which appears to be the case (the writer lives in Toronto). Here in Seattle nobody would spend so many words writing about the hoodie. People wear them. Business professionals wear them. Sometimes even CEOs. It's not a symbol, it's just clothing.
You missed the entire point of the essay. 1) The hoodie is more than just an article of clothing, and 2) it wasn't really about the hoodies.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie
by InclinedPlane on Monday January 28, 2013 @03:30AM
(#5127680)
No, I got it. It's overwrought symbolism posing as profundity.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie
by alanctgardner2 on Monday January 28, 2013 @09:42AM
(#5128649)
I have no idea what geographic location has to do with writing quality; I live near Toronto, I thought it was overwrought and pointless too. You're kind of reinforcing my negative stereotypes of West Coast people.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg's Hoodie
by InclinedPlane on Monday January 28, 2013 @03:52PM
(#5130563)
It's not about writing quality but about clothing. On the West Coast there's far less of an expectation that business professionals should "dress up". If someone is wearing a hoodie in Seattle or Portland it's not something to comment on, lots of people wear hoodies, even CEOs sometimes. From a West Coast perspective commenting on wearing a hoodie seems a bit like commenting about wearing jeans to work.
>It is difficult to imagine a more suitable uniform for the notoriously private CEO of a company dedicated to expanding our ideas of what should be public.
>June 2, 2010, Zuckerberg, hoodie removed, begins answering Mossberg’s question.
Honestly, this seriously reminds me of the kinds of essays that most students fall into the trap of writing in English classes in school - fake certitude, speaking in absolutes, a pervasive tone of academic hysteria, and drawing parallels and implications by mere association. In my view, it tries to dissemble a sense of profundity, however hollow.
The final sentence is a particularly egregious example of drawing an association out of thin air. This essay may as well have introduced itself as studying the symbolic motif of the hoodie and its role in the constant conflict between privacy and surveillance in the literary work Facebook, by Reality.
EDIT: I would like to lightheartedly add that these essays were always really fun for me to write in school because I would get top marks for them despite knowing how meaningless they were.