Re:A farewell to bioinformatics (2012)
by aheilbut on Sunday January 27, 2013 @01:15AM
(#5123339)
The smoking gun was an error, but there were something like 9 Potti papers that ended up getting retracted. There's no way that someone could have accidentally made that many mistakes...
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Interestingly, the fraudsters were caught because of a false claim on a CV, and that finally destroyed their creditability.
It is intentional fraud, no doubt about it; they restarted halted clinical trials. I was just pointing out they did sloppy work too.
Re:A farewell to bioinformatics (2012)
by michaelhoffman on Sunday January 27, 2013 @02:07AM
(#5123506)
They were caught due to their bad behavior in the case you listed earlier. But Duke refused to do anything about it until Anil Potti's false claim of a Rhodes Scholarship came to light.
Wow, that's messed up.
Fundamental methodological error -> "Come on, these are competent people, you have to trust that whatever error they made didn't effect the final result."
False claim of accolade -> "How dare you fucking try to pass off this garbage as legitimate science?!?!?"
Welcome to academia