That said, I agree that this example sucked: the argument wasn't even that strong, party because I get the impression that Stallman doesn't really "get" Java (based not just on this example, but from other situations where Java comes up; it just seems like he never looked at it very closely to see what it really wasn't actually capable of: he seems to give it much more credit than it is due). The comments on the mailing list seemed to defeat his argument, which is why I continue to be confused that the discussion didn't continue.
As for why more people don't know about it, I don't know: it was a somewhat big deal on a bunch of mailing lists (again: it hit freebsd-advocacy and turned into a major event, somewhat bolstered by the GCC Introspector guy I mentioned elsewhere in this thread getting involved an sharing his stories as well). I can only imagine that not enough people care about mailing list history. :(
The fact that RMS would tell someone to take a GPLed extension to GPLed code off their website, and never mention they exist, seems fundamentally against the principles of free software. How was this not a controversy of the highest order at the time? I'm amazed I missed it.