Re:United States Sentencing Commission website hacked
by youngerdryas on Saturday January 26, 2013 @07:16PM
(#5122420)
You watched that video and found it be credible? You are the fodder for their tomfoolery. Now I have nothing against pranks, but there is a legitimate cause here. Scientific papers from public funding should be freely available. Superhero gibberish, while entertaining, will not help.
Re:United States Sentencing Commission website hacked
by rdtsc on Saturday January 26, 2013 @08:26PM
(#5122624)
I didn't find it credible but I believe it inspiring (for many).
> Superhero gibberish, while entertaining, will not help.
Superman, Batman, etc... No country loves them some super hero stuff better than Americans. I don't think anyone including the authors this this video to be a documentary, it is a piece of propaganda, a call to action. Do they expect the govt. to realistically accept their conditions and conduct an overnight reform of DOJ? I am guessing not.
Re:United States Sentencing Commission website hacked
by youngerdryas on Saturday January 26, 2013 @09:50PM
(#5122844)
>it is a piece of propaganda
That is not not a valid excuse in free countries. Where are you from?
[Shurgs].
> You and your first world problems have NO IDEA how to fight for freedom.
Flaunting your experience living in a totalitarian regime to scold those first world kids might not be as convincing, than, say, if you just skipped that part.
Someone else can always trump that "well, my family members were tortured" so "don't tell me about your experience".
> If you really want to learn about effective popular action to bring about more freedom, point your Web browser to the Albert Einstein Institute publications
Those are good resources and it is good to point them out. However the situation and the initial conditions in each country are different. What works in Burma might not work in US.
> ... before they were adopted, on the example of Minnesota's sentencing guidelines, federal sentences were just about wholly indeterminate,
Ok so how do you explain what happened and how downloads of scientific articles can result in threatening someone with 35+ years in prison. Isn't this exactly the area to attack, just because it was random before now it is predictably horrible. I would take the randomness again. At least then someone can point to the judge and say, this judge is out of control, they are responsible, they are ruining lives and wasting tax dollars.
Now they have a list of minimum requirements and they can all point their finger too everyone dismisses the accusations with "But I am just a part of the system".
The goal is not necessarily to remove the sentencing guidelines but to make them sane. You assume it the goal is to remove them.
> I know actual freedom fighters, that is publishers of opposition magazines and organizers of nonviolent protests, from Taiwan.
Again, Taiwan is not US. By comparing the two you are also implicitly lowering the standard and expectation for US. The assumption being "US is just like Burma and Taiwan, what works there should be applied here". I think first we should examine that assumption. Pretty scary. Here is a country that managed to convince most of the its population and those from other countries that it is qualitatively superior. Founded on unbiased justice, representative democracy, everyone has a right to happiness. There is freedom to prosper. And now we are left comparing it to Burma. That is interesting.
Absolute comparisons are good to conduct (when possible). We are still better than North Korea or Eritrea. So we are looking good there. But there is also a relative comparison -- between the image a country projects of itself (via propaganda, or what most people expect from it) and its reality. There is also comparison between the countries at roughly the same level of development (comparing Burma to Taiwan) but then also comparing US with say Norway.
In this case the most important is comparing US to the image most expect from US. Here the situation is not pretty.
Also, I don't necessarily agree with attacking websites, but I don't necessarily disagree it. If it reveals corruption, good, make those servers burn. We don't know what it will reveal, so I can't say if this is effective or desirable.