News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blowing the Whistle on the Mortgage Bubble by 1123581321 on Saturday January 26, 2013 @12:17AM (#5119350)
I wish you wouldn't have been snarky. The next time you write a post like this, I suggest explaining what is socialism in your post, how it differs from what the person described, and providing them with a word that better fits what they were saying.

Also, I don't see why if using the correct word is called "accurate," then using the wrong word is called "dogma" instead of "inaccurate." Your implication was that someone who uses the word socialist when they mean to use another word isn't thinking for themselves, I suppose, but you don't actually have any reason to think that, and even if you did, you would still want to stick to educating them instead of snarkily insulting them.

Finally, I'd like you to imagine what Hacker News would be like if people corrected technical ignorance with "CS 101. It ain't that difficult." It's a completely unhelpful thing to say. If you believe someone should actually take a 100-level political science class, then please be helpful and suggest a free university course.

I do believe you meant to help so I hope you'll incorporate these suggestions the next time you correct a political post.

Re:Blowing the Whistle on the Mortgage Bubble by deveac on Saturday February 02, 2013 @01:01PM (#5156714)
>next time you write a post like this, I suggest explaining what is socialism in your post

I believe linking to the wiki and clearly directing him to the exact place in the wiki (the first line) communicates the information very effectively. Barrier to entry is zero and if he wants to keep reading he can go more in depth.

>I don't see why if using the correct word is called "accurate," then using the wrong word is called "dogma"

Using the wrong word is not, by definition, dogma. Dogma was inferred from other verbiage in his post, and is my opinion and the impression I got from his language.

>I'd like you to imagine what Hacker News would be like if people corrected technical ignorance with...

See above, -I don't really think this was technical ignorance. Of course I could be wrong, but that's not the premise I'm working with, or the impression I got. Hence the snark.

But as I already mentioned, I shouldn't have bothered to reply at all to what I saw as a dogmatic post. I think there's and adage about what to do when you're coming up short with niceties that applies here...