News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by richardlblair on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:26PM (#5117162)
Let's not all sit here on our laptops, in our comfortable lives and try to understand the political complexities of societies where underage labour is common place.

Let's not pretend to understand, and let's not pretend that we all have some high moral duty to "protect" these children.

But, while you sip you tripple tall americano while reading forbes magazine pretending to be an expert on poverty and politics take a second to think a 12 year old boy who just lost his families only source of income, only source of food, and only source of life. These people live in a society where the cost of your fucking americano goes a long way.

So stop pretending. Because you have no fucking idea.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by rz2k on Friday January 25, 2013 @03:04PM (#5117333)
Regardless of what type of coffee people drink or how they drink it, what is the best way to understand the short and long term impacts of child labor on quality of life?

A researcher looking at working conditions alone, without considering whether the alternate is worse conditions on a rural farm or some form of schooling is a sloppy researcher. It is a sloppy researcher, too, who doesn't acknowledge that labor-intensive production is a source of wealth that aids economic convergence for poorer countries.

The perspective of children living in poverty informs a comprehensive understanding of the dynamics of child labor and growth economics, but it is not the final word, nor is the child remotely likely to provide any better policy guidance than someone who has the training and tools for sophisticated analysis.

Is squeamishness and moral indignation a blunt tool? Much as children can be easily compelled to act against their own economic self interest, squeamishness can lead adults to act counter-productively in pursuit of their loftiest ideals. That doesn't mean that people should just throw up their hands in despair, or defer to the idea that whatever factors lead to current conditions must be ideal factors.

These aren't new topics, and there is no shortage of research and findings on when, why, or how different types of labor are a benefit or detriment to poor economies:

http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=economic+growth+%22child...

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by _pmf_ on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:35PM (#5117205)
Very sound reasoning. By the very same reasoning, the debate about whether to abolish slavery (in the US) should still be in full rage. After all, who could definitely predict whether those poor people would be able to survive without their masters providing them food and shelter and protecting them from the harsh reality (with hardly a benefit for themselves)?

But I'm sure you will be able to demonstrate why this is not an appropriate analogy.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by richardlblair on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:57PM (#5117310)
Enslaving people because of their race in a country that was otherwise prosperous, and hiring children in an economy and society where any thing else is nearly impossible are two entirely different things.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by king_jester on Friday January 25, 2013 @05:15PM (#5118006)
Slavery was the primary economic engine for a long, long time in US and its originating colonies and it was a primary reason for the economic prosperity and viability of colonies.

I agree with you that they are not the same, but both political and social wrongs that can and should be addressed (yes slavery still exists in the US, both de facto and actual i.e. human trafficking).

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by brockf on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:30PM (#5117183)
Along the way, your comment went from the collective "we"/"our" to "you". So I have to ask, do you have any idea?
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by richardlblair on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:33PM (#5117196)
No, and I don't pretend to. Unlike too many in this thread.

No one here can have any idea what those poor people are going through.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by rscale on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:51PM (#5117278)
I found myself thinking of this essay by Mike Turitzin as I read your post:

http://www.miketuritzin.com/writing/how-to-be-a-naysayer/

It's clear, concise, and well worth consideration.