News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by DanBC on Friday January 25, 2013 @01:38PM (#5116921)
The problem with underage workers is:

1) Education is a right which far too many people miss out on

2) Children's bodies and brains are still forming and so making them repeat actions many times per day is intrinsically harmful and the lack of mental development is similarly harmful

3) Children in factory jobs removes opportunities for adults to do the same jobs.

4) The pay is rarely "fair"; the conditions are rarely "okay".

You're right that it's better that children earn a bit of cash to help with family bills. But that would be better done by paying the parents a fair wage.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by drcube on Friday January 25, 2013 @01:47PM (#5116967)
You're right that children shouldn't have to work. But in the situations where they do anyway, it serves them better to fix the underlying problem -- poverty -- than to fire them and send them right back to the conditions they tried to escape. Because when legal means of earning money aren't available, what's left but gangs, robbery, drugs and prostitution?

Again, I'm not talking about kids who are forced into work, aka slaves. I'm also not trying to implicate Apple here. It seems like they're doing the right thing by educating the underage workers and guaranteeing them their previous income.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by DanBC on Friday January 25, 2013 @06:14PM (#5118305)
You're right - children tend to work because they need to work, not for fun or to get a bit of cash for nonsense.

But that's why it's important to have strict laws. Desperate people are easy to exploit.

I guess it's better that they're exploited in a clean factory rather than sold to be indentured slaves or worse.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by ataggart on Friday January 25, 2013 @01:57PM (#5117022)
In a society with significant child labor, it's not clear to me how "just pay the parents more" is a serious response. When significant child labor exists, it does so for a reason.

Given that parents would probably prefer their kids get an education instead of working, it's not clear to me that depriving them of the option to work in a factory will result in the child going to school. In all likelihood, the child will continue to work, albeit at their next-best (perhaps illicit) option; their best option (via revealed preference) having been removed by enlightened westerners who don't have to face the same constrained set of choices.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by pflats on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:15PM (#5117106)
Let's look, amorally, at why China has a serious interest in not having child labor.

1. It cheapens their labor, and trades an adult's job for a child. Most of the money for the jobs with potential child labor is coming from out of the country; why not soak them for a few more Yuan per person?

2. It upsets their primary business partners and reinforces the "China regularly violates human rights" stereotype that the West uses as a cudgel.

3. It trades a worker's future gains for much less siginificant short-term gains. China wants more highly-skilled jobs for its young people. It wants more Chinese luxury goods, and wants them sold the world 'round. Every child working in a factor is another child that isn't getting the education to make China a bigger world power and take the reins of a given industry.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by ataggart on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:29PM (#5117180)
All of which is irrelevant to the fact that the best option for many children (again, revealed preference) is to work, and depriving them of that option is likely to lead to a net worse condition.

But to your point, I'm quite certain that "China" would prefer to have an economy sufficiently productive and wealthy that child labor is no longer a choice parents feel they need to make. Banning the effect does not change the cause.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by jimbokun on Friday January 25, 2013 @03:18PM (#5117390)
"When significant child labor exists, it does so for a reason."

The reason is that it is in the interest of wealthy factory owners to keep the cost of labor as low as possible, just like when child labor was prevalent in the United States.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by ams6110 on Friday January 25, 2013 @06:15PM (#5118306)
You might want to look into why it was possible for child labor to end, as well. Every economy that has transitioned from rural/agricultural to urban/industrial has gone through a period of "exploitative" labor practices. I'm not sure it's necessarily inevitable, but it seems to be the norm.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by ataggart on Friday January 25, 2013 @05:53PM (#5118205)
Lower costs explain why child labor is in demand, but says nothing about supply, namely why parents send their children off to work in a factory, something parents in productive, wealthy economies are unlikely to do.
Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by DanBC on Friday January 25, 2013 @06:18PM (#5118324)
Which is why it's important to give parents a working wage.

Part of that is strict laws about child labour, to avoid factory owners exploiting poor people. Creating a level field makes it easier for ethical employers to follow their ethics.

It would be nice if some of the premium paid for some products in the west was used to pay poor workers better, or used for health and educational projects.

Re:Apple fires Chinese supplier for using underage workers by username3 on Friday January 25, 2013 @02:51PM (#5117277)
How is this different from children learning programming or a musical instrument early?